A Silver Loon Sculpture Now Anchors the Corner of Snelling and University Avenues

A silver loon sculpture now anchors the corner of Snelling and University avenues, marking the most visible sign yet that United Village’s first phase is nearing completion.

The $250 million Allianz Field opened in 2019 on a former Metro Transit bus lot. Minnesota United owner Bill McGuire said he has since invested about $170 million of his own money in the surrounding United Village development, Star Tribune reported.

Midway Diner and Picco Pizza + Gelateria opened this fall. A four-level glass office building stands fully leased, with three companies moving headquarters to the site, McGuire said. The adjacent 158-room boutique hotel is nearing completion, along with an inclusive playground, parking ramp and public art.

“Make it where somebody says, ‘Gosh, I want to be there,’” McGuire told Star Tribune. “I want to be there because of where it is, because it’s got transportation, because I can walk out this afternoon and throw my blanket on the grass and sit in the sun.”

The project has stumbled over permitting disputes, the pandemic and civil unrest after the murder of George Floyd. McGuire cited a one-acre public green space, originally part of Phase 1, now two years behind schedule.

“There’s no excuse for that,” McGuire said.

Mayor Kaohly Her said her administration has worked to coordinate city processes, including “working through very complicated regulations,” with developers. A dispute over “green infrastructure” fees for a $6 million stormwater system in September pushed back hotel construction. Funds are now in escrow to resume work.

McGuire estimated $30 million in “wasted money” because of delays at a St. Paul Chamber event Tuesday.

Phase 2 remains undefined. McGuire has shown renderings for an outdoor amphitheater, indoor music venue, daycare and housing, but has no set plan or confirmed construction schedule. He wants the city to build out the public street grid first. Those projects are not in St. Paul’s 2027 budget proposal.

“The city does not have money lying around,” Her said, when asked about the street projects and additional help for United Village as she struggles to keep street lights on and libraries open.

Neighbors are split. Timothy Wilson, owner of Urban Lights record store, welcomes the changes. “Hopefully, it’ll bring people,” he said.

Tammy Davis, a lifelong Midway resident, sees little benefit.

“I don’t think the loon statue does anything for the community at all,” she said. “The neighborhood’s trashed when they’re gone.”

Jonathan Oppenheimer, a St. Paul social worker who served on former Chris Coleman’s community advisory committee in 2015 and 2016, argues the city ignored evidence that stadiums don’t promote economic development.

“We don’t have any housing,” Oppenheimer said. “We certainly don’t have any affordable housing, and we’ve taken lots of land off the tax rolls. This is a big vanity project for Bill McGuire. This was never about Midway and the people of the Midway.”

Mike Reynolds, a Hamline University professor, said students from nearby colleges rarely venture to the area. “They’re scared of coming down here, which is kind of silly,” he said. “What’s more, he said, there isn’t much for students to do.”

Scott Berger, a neighbor, said the development is “in transition, but as of right now, it’s not terribly useful.”

On gamedays, the picture shifts. Wes Burdine, owner of the Black Hart bar, said revenue has doubled since he took over in 2018.

“People who put businesses in that serve needs can thrive, and I think that we’ve shown that,” he said.

Daniela Lorenz, a project manager for United Village with St. Paul’s Department of Planning and Economic Development, said recent investments elsewhere in the Midway are connected to the construction. “Developers are starting to see the Midway as more viable, and a lot of that is a result of Dr. McGuire and his team’s willingness to come in and have the vision,” she said.

Coleman pointed to The Pivot and The Pitch, two apartment buildings across Snelling Avenue built five years ago, as housing spurred by the stadium. Hamline-Midway has seen some of the fastest-rising property values in the city, though residents note that means rising property taxes.

McGuire recently bought the site of a long-vacant CVS, demolished this year, and proposed apartments, shops, a small grocery, restaurant, barbershop and family practice clinic.

United Village project advisor Mike Hahm said it is “very challenging to see a path forward for housing on this site.”