African Union Launches AfCRA to Challenge Rating Costs

The African Union launched the Africa Credit Rating Agency (AfCRA) on October 7 in Abuja, Nigeria, aiming to challenge sovereign assessments by Moody’s, S&P Global Ratings and Fitch Ratings that African leaders argue do not adequately account for the continent’s economic structures and circumstances.

Headquartered in Port Louis, Mauritius, AfCRA plans to issue its first sovereign ratings by the end of March. Interim Chief Executive Sifiso Falala told Al Jazeera the agency is already in discussions with 15 governments, with research scheduled in Mauritius, Kenya, Togo, the Seychelles and Burundi.

The Bottom Line:

  • A 2023 UNDP study estimated that subjectivities in sovereign credit ratings cost African countries $74.5 billion through excessive interest payments and foregone lending.
  • Moody’s argues that four decades of default data show a B-rated African sovereign carries the same ~5% one-year default probability as a B-rated peer elsewhere.
  • AfCRA’s challenge will be to demonstrate that its assessments are more comprehensive, transparent and predictive of actual credit risk.

The $74.5 Billion Argument

The financial stakes are concrete. The United Nations Development Programme estimated that subjectivities in sovereign credit ratings cost African countries $74.5 billion through excessive interest payments and foregone lending. Falala put the human face on the data: “A significant number of African countries carry speculative-grade ratings despite having no history of sovereign default.”

Can Africa’s new credit rating agency change how the continent is assessed
Photo: news-ajel.com

That claim cuts to the core of the methodology dispute. African governments have long argued that international rating methodologies do not adequately account for the continent’s economic structures and circumstances.

Moody’s Pushback: Default Data Is Color-Blind

At a Chatham House discussion in June, Marie Diron from Moody’s presented a direct rebuttal. The agency’s analysis of four decades of global sovereign default data showed that African countries with a particular rating had broadly the same probability of default as equally rated borrowers elsewhere. A B rating implies a 5% one-year default probability regardless of whether it was African or from another region.

Diron’s argument: if the ratings were systematically biased, African default rates would exceed the model’s predictions. They do not. The major agencies — Moody’s, S&P Global Ratings and Fitch Ratings — have disputed suggestions that their assessments systematically disadvantage African borrowers.

Local Data, Informal Economies, and the Coverage Gap

Abdussalam Muazu, an associate chartered economist at the Institute of Chartered Economists of Nigeria, told Al Jazeera that limited information about African borrowers has contributed to the uncertainty investors factor into lending decisions. “African governments and companies often pay more to borrow than their ratings suggest, partly because investors know too little about them and price in the uncertainty.”

Muazu highlighted structural blind spots: “The big agencies have few analysts on the ground, and much of Africa’s economy runs through informal trade, mobile money and community finance that is hard to measure from outside.”

Can africas credit rating agency change how the
Photo: khanlist.com

Dayo Obisan, a financial market professional, told Al Jazeera that African countries need rating methodologies that better reflect their economic circumstances and their access to capital. “The compelling question is how does Africa ensure its peculiarities are factored into the determination of its perception as a sovereign and its access to much-needed capital, which rides on this perception?”

The Independence Trap

An institution established partly in response to dissatisfaction with existing ratings must demonstrate that its own assessments are independent of political pressure and the interests of the governments and companies it evaluates.

“An institution established partly in response to dissatisfaction with existing ratings must demonstrate that its own assessments are independent of political pressure and the interests of the governments and companies it evaluates.”

Falala acknowledged the scepticism, telling Al Jazeera the agency was not seeking confrontation with established rating providers but saw considerable opportunity to rebuild confidence through transparency and analytical independence. His objective is to produce more accurate ratings of Africa in collaboration with established rating agencies. “Importantly, we believe that a stronger AfCRA will contribute to a stronger credit rating industry overall,” he said.

What Investors Need to See

Their influence will depend on whether investors consider the assessments credible and useful in making investment decisions.

AfCRA’s first sovereign ratings, due by end of March, are the opening bid in a negotiation regarding the continent’s economic realities. “What strengthens AfCRA should ultimately strengthen the credibility of the entire credit rating industry,” Falala said. “Africa needs more credible assessments, not competing narratives.”

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and market analysis purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, or legal advice. Always consult with a certified financial professional before making investment decisions.