Amazon lit up its New York City app on Thursday with a blunt warning: the City Council’s Delivery Protection Act could add up to $5 to every order.
The alert, which appeared as shoppers scrolled for groceries and household goods, marks an escalation in a months-long fight over Intro 518. The bill, sponsored by Councilwoman Tiffany Cabán of Queens, would require last-mile delivery operators to obtain a city license and directly employ the workers who sort and drop packages — effectively ending the subcontractor model Amazon relies on across the five boroughs.
The math behind the warning
Amazon ties the $5 figure to a study by consulting firm AKRF estimating the legislation could raise annual household costs by $409 to $664. The company did not explain how that yearly range translates to a per-order surcharge, but it argues compliance would force a fundamental restructuring of its network.
In testimony submitted to the Council earlier this year, Amazon said it works with more than 40 local delivery businesses employing over 5,000 people in New York City. “If this legislation passes, we’d no longer be able to work with them, and we’d be forced to consider moving our operations outside of the city,” the company tells customers in the in-app message.
Council fires back
Speaker Julie Menin called the campaign “deceptive.”
“It defies logic that Amazon, a $3 trillion corporation, would raise New Yorkers’ cost of living if it’s forced to adhere to basic regulations and worker protections.”
Menin said in a statement Thursday. Mayor Zohran Mamdani echoed the sentiment on X: “If Jeff Bezos adds $5 to your order, it’s not because of City Council’s efforts to protect workers’ rights and keep our streets safe. It’s greed. Pass the Delivery Protection Act.”
The Department of Consumer and Worker Protection has endorsed the bill, arguing it would strengthen accountability for labor violations, though the agency acknowledged concerns with certain provisions.
A vote could come in days
The Council has two remaining scheduled meetings this year — December 3 and December 17. For a December 3 vote, the bill would need to appear on the agenda by November 25, starting the required eight-day aging period. Negotiations over the final text, including whether a direct-hire mandate remains, are ongoing between Amazon and Menin’s office.
“The concept that the direct-hire mandate is totally coming out is not true — the direct hire mandate is still on the table,” a source close to the talks said. “That’s one of the core pieces that is being negotiated at this point.”
Subcontractors sound the alarm
Outside Cabán’s district office Thursday, a rally organized by New York Delivers — a coalition of Amazon subcontractors — highlighted the stakes for the small businesses that would lose their contracts under a direct-hire requirement.

Kris Basmagy, owner of DashWave Delivery, a Manhattan subcontractor, said he believes the process is moving a lot faster than any of them imagined, that they are in a tornado, and that there is increased urgency.
Within six hours of launching the in-app appeal, Amazon said roughly 20,000 New Yorkers had clicked through to contact their Council members.
Cabán, a former public defender born in Richmond Hill, Queens, to Puerto Rican parents, first drew national attention with her 2019 primary run for Queens District Attorney, narrowly losing after a historic manual recount.
She later worked as a national organizer for the Working Families Party before winning the 22nd Council District seat in 2021. In September 2024 she became the first Council member to publicly call for Mayor Eric Adams to resign amid federal investigations.
What happens next
The bill does not impose a $5 fee; Amazon argues the operational changes the bill demands would drive up costs. FedEx and other carriers with similar last-mile networks would also fall under the licensing rules.
With a supermajority of Council members and the mayor publicly backing the measure, the next week of closed-door drafting will decide whether New York becomes the first major city to mandate direct employment in the gig-heavy delivery sector — and whether Amazon follows through on its threat to move sortation centers across the Hudson.
Worth a look
- No. 5 Virginia Tech Shuts Out The Citadel 45-0 Behind Seven Technical Falls
- ‘GTA 6’ Release Live Updates: Reviews, Memes and More as Gamers Explore and React to Leonida After 13 Long Years
- Amazon Uses Homepage Banner, App Pop-Up to Lobby NYC Shoppers Against Delivery Protection Act (world-today-news.com)