Springfield-based Baystate Health sued Commonwealth Care Alliance on Monday, alleging the insurer owes nearly $14 million for care already delivered, and said it will not renew its contract with the payer effective Jan. 1, 2027.
The filing in Suffolk County Superior Court claims CCA — acquired by CareSource last year — improperly recouped payments and violated agreement terms for services rendered to its members, Becker’s Payer Issues reported. Baystate said it turned to litigation after direct talks failed to resolve the dispute.
“Baystate cannot continue to contract with an insurer that does not pay for the care we provide for its members in accordance with the terms of the agreement in place,” the system said in a Nov. 17 news release.
“With nearly $14 million owed for care already delivered, these are the resources that support the services families in our communities depend on. As a safety-net healthcare provider, we have a responsibility to protect those resources and ensure we can continue to meet the healthcare needs of our region.”
A CCA spokesperson told Becker’s on Wednesday that the insurer has been negotiating in good faith to extend its agreement with Baystate and is urging the health system to resume talks so patient care is not disrupted.
“Patients in Western Massachusetts should not unnecessarily be put in the middle of a financial dispute between two healthcare organizations they depend on,” the spokesperson said. CCA said that Baystate lodged a contractual dispute in Suffolk County Superior Court in June and maintained that the current legal process should settle the disagreement instead of putting patients’ access to care at risk.
“While we continue working toward a renewed contract, we have started notifying members of the potential network change in accordance with regulatory requirements, and are prepared to help them navigate their care options,” CCA said in the statement. “We remain ready to reach a reasonable agreement with Baystate Health that protects our members’ access to care while sustainably managing the public funds entrusted to us.”
Baystate Health traces its roots to a 1974 merger of Springfield Hospital Medical Center and Wesson Women’s Hospital that created the Medical Center of Western Massachusetts. In 1976, a further merger with Wesson Memorial Hospital established Baystate Medical Center, then the second-largest hospital in New England with 1,036 beds.
The system was reorganized in 1983 into Baystate Health Systems, now Baystate Health, and today operates four acute-care hospitals with over 1,000 licensed beds and the region’s only Level I trauma center at its flagship Springfield campus.
Patients enrolled in CCA plans will retain in-network access to Baystate providers through Dec. 31, including providers joining the health system from Hartford, Conn.-based Trinity Health of New England. Baystate acquired Mercy Medical Center from Trinity Health of New England on Nov. 1. Baystate plans to reach out to affected patients in the coming weeks with details about the network change and alternative coverage options.