Black Hills Energy customers in western South Dakota will not see a new monthly surcharge hit their bills in December, after the utility backed down Thursday from its push to start collecting before state regulators finish their review.
The decision spares roughly 75,000 residential and business customers from a second rate increase in as many months. The South Dakota Public Utilities Commission approved a standard rate hike on Nov. 5 that already adds about $16 to the typical household bill, South Dakota Searchlight reported.
Black Hills had asked to layer an interim surcharge on top of that — initially $19.70 a month for a customer using 650 kilowatt-hours, later revised to $17.26 at 600 kilowatt-hours — to recoup construction costs for its new Lange II natural-gas plant in Rapid City.
“I would encourage Black Hills to figure out what the right number is, and then communicate that so we can all be using the same number there,” Commissioner Chris Nelson said during a hearing Tuesday, flagging the shifting estimates.

The legal fight over interim authority
Commission staff objected to the interim request, arguing state law does not grant utilities the power to impose a surcharge before final approval — authority that exists in general rate cases but not, in staff’s view, for this type of plant-recovery mechanism. Black Hills had wanted to begin collecting Dec. 1, aiming to recover roughly $37.5 million annually toward the approximately $320 million project.
Under a stipulation filed Thursday, the utility agreed not to seek implementation before Feb. 1 or the plant’s commercial operation date, whichever comes later. The three elected commissioners voted unanimously to defer the underlying legal question indefinitely.
“I think there’s a real legal question as to whether you can even do that,” Nelson said. “Hopefully, we don’t have to adjudicate that, but if we do at some point, well, that’s why we’re here.”
Plant delay changes the calculus
An attorney for Black Hills told the commission Thursday that the Lange II startup has been pushed back, which factored into the decision to withdraw the interim request. The surcharge, if ultimately approved, would be subject to annual review.

The episode plays out against a larger corporate backdrop: Black Hills Energy and NorthWestern Energy recently completed a merger forming Bright Horizon Energy, a combined utility serving 2.2 million electric and gas customers across eight states. Montana’s approval of that merger is being challenged in court. For now, Commissioner Kristie Fiegen said in June, the two South Dakota operations “continue to operate and file for rates separately.”
The South Dakota Public Utilities Commission traces its roots to the Dakota Territory Board of Railroad Commissioners, created in 1885. It became an elected body in 1893, and the legislature renamed it the Public Utilities Commission in 1940. Its three commissioners serve staggered six-year terms; Republicans have held a majority since 2003.
The commission’s next move on the surcharge itself remains unscheduled.