Both sides in the fight over Nashville’s Fairgrounds Speedway sued the Davidson County Election Commission, each arguing the other’s maneuvering threatens to corrupt the charter amendment process ahead of a summer 2027 vote.
The dueling lawsuits, filed in Davidson County Chancery Court, landed after the commission certified a Restore Our Fairgrounds petition on October 16 with 47,679 valid signatures, News Channel 5 Nashville (WTVF) reported. That certification teed up a ballot measure that would end auto racing at one of the country’s oldest tracks and convert the site to green space, affordable housing and a cleaned-up Brown’s Creek.
The math behind the certification is the first flashpoint. The Metro Charter requires signatures from 10 percent of registered voters as of the filing date. The commission calculated that threshold using only “active” voters — 40,194 names — citing Tennessee Code Annotated 2-2-106, which excludes inactive registrations from the county total.
Decline to Sign, the opposition group backed by Speedway Motorsports and Darden Copeland’s Calvert Street Group, argues that move unlawfully dropped the bar from roughly 47,000 signatures, leaving virtually no margin for error on the 47,679 the coalition turned in.
“This case asks a simple question: Will fraud be allowed to put a measure on the ballot to change the city’s charter?” a Decline to Sign spokesperson said in a statement provided to News Channel 5 Nashville (WTVF).
“We are asking the Davidson County Chancery Court to overturn the Election Commission’s October 16, 2026 approval of a petition that would end auto racing at the Nashville Fairgrounds Speedway due to the rampant forgery and fraud in the petition submitted by Citizens Against Racetrack Expansion (CARE).”
Decline to Sign’s complaint goes well beyond the threshold dispute. The group submitted more than 2,000 names to the commission before certification, alleging those voters were either misled about the petition’s purpose or had their signatures forged outright. The lawsuit includes more than 50 affidavits, some from former Tennessee residents who say they haven’t lived in the state for years and want their names removed.
The filing also cites the commission’s own internal notes, which Decline to Sign says show reviewers spotted patterns of abuse by multiple canvassers, yet counted undated entries, duplicates, signatures from people not registered when they signed, and names withdrawn before filing.
Restore Our Fairgrounds, led in part by former Metro attorney Saul Solomon, fired back with its own suit claiming the commission wrongly rejected more than 700 signatures that should have counted. The coalition says those voters were incorrectly labeled “not registered” when they were, in fact, on the rolls.
Solomon is asking the court to consider his challenge only if Decline to Sign’s case succeeds in stripping enough names to push the total below the certification line — a conditional defense that shows how tight the numbers are.
“Nashvillians are tired of this constant drumbeat of frivolous litigation,” said Heidi Basgall Favorite, co-founder of Restore Our Fairgrounds, in a statement to News Channel 5 Nashville (WTVF). “The fact is: Decline to Sign is a thinly veiled political operation backed by Speedway Motorsports and Darden Copeland’s Calvert Street Group, which has a documented history of deceiving the public.”
Basgall Favorite also pointed to a Confederate flag displayed on a race car at the speedway this month as evidence the track’s culture is out of step with the community. Track officials said the driver apologized, but the Nashville NAACP chapter demanded accountability for allowing a symbol of white supremacy in a public space, according to News Channel 5 Nashville (WTVF).
The legal skirmishing is not new. Martin ruled last month that the commission was not required to create a process allowing voters to withdraw their names from a petition, though she noted opponents have other legal avenues to challenge certification.
Much of the controversy has centered on whether canvassers misled signers by failing to explain the measure could end racing at the fairgrounds entirely. With the threshold dispute, the forgery allegations, and the rejected-signature counterclaim all now before the same court, the next ruling will decide whether Nashville voters ever get a say on the speedway’s future — or whether the fight stays locked in litigation through 2027.