Brandon Oetken Ruled Incompetent to Stand Trial in Deputy Katherine Frank’s Death

A judge ruled Friday that Brandon Oetken, the man charged with fatally shooting Minnehaha County Deputy Katherine Frank, is incompetent to stand trial, Dakota News Now reported.

Second Judicial Circuit Court Judge Susan Sabers ordered Oetken, 39, committed to the South Dakota Human Services Center in Yankton for “treatment and restoration,” according to a court order filed Friday. Two court-appointed psychiatrists — Sanford Health’s Sarah Flynn and Avera Medical Group’s Madeline Nykamp — found Oetken unable to understand the proceedings against him or assist in his own defense, Minnehaha County State’s Attorney Daniel Haggar said Friday.

To stand trial and face charges, a defendant needs to be deemed “competent to understand the nature of the proceeding and capable of assisting their attorney,” Haggar said. During the hearing, Oetken did not speak beyond confirming the pronunciation of his last name for the judge.

The ruling puts the criminal case on hold for at least four months while Oetken undergoes restoration treatment, either at the facility or through a jail-based program determined by the Human Services Center. If he remains incompetent after that period, the center’s director must report to the court on whether he is likely to become competent and when.

Under South Dakota law, if Judge Sabers finds he is unlikely to ever regain competency, the charges must be dismissed, though prosecutors could then seek civil commitment if he is considered a danger to himself or others.

The charges stem from October 9, when deputies arrived at Oetken’s residence near 41st Street and Ellis Road to execute a mental health detention warrant. According to the Division of Criminal Investigation, Oetken did not comply with verbal requests to leave the house, pointed a firearm at deputies and fired once, striking Frank, 26.

A second deputy returned fire, hitting Oetken with a non-life-threatening wound. Frank died October 12. Oetken faces counts of first-degree murder of a law enforcement officer, alleging premeditation, and second-degree murder of a law enforcement officer, alleging an act without regard for human life — charges that carry a maximum penalty of life in prison or death.

Minnehaha County, the state’s most populous county with 197,214 residents in 2020, takes its name from the Sioux word Mnihaha, meaning “rapid water” or “waterfall.” Created on April 5, 1862, and organized in 1868, it contains over 22.56% of South Dakota’s population and includes Sioux Falls, the state’s largest city.

The next step is a review hearing after the initial four-month treatment period, at which point the court will assess whether further restoration efforts are warranted or whether the statutory path toward dismissal and potential civil commitment begins.