The Denver Broncos handed Riley Moss a four-year, $67 million extension Thursday, then let it leak that they have not opened serious talks with the other starting cornerback whose contract expires after this season.
Chris Tomasson of the Denver Gazette reported the silence around Ja’Quan McMillian on the same day Moss’s deal became official, and Denver Sports published the details hours later. The timing frames a stark choice: the team has now committed more than $16.75 million a year to Moss — 23rd among NFL cornerbacks — while McMillian, arguably the league’s premier slot defender, plays out a one-year, $5.7 million tender.
“We shall see if this means Broncos have chosen to extend Riley Moss at this point over JMac with thinking they also have Jahdae Barron,” Tomasson wrote.

That question has hovered over the facility since April, when Denver used a first-round pick on Barron, a versatile defensive back who played nickel at Texas. The rookie has already seen meaningful snaps in 2026 while Moss missed time with a rib injury and a concussion.
If the front office views Barron as a plug-and-play replacement inside, the math on McMillian shifts — especially with Pat Surtain II locked in at $24 million annually through 2029.
McMillian’s resume makes the standoff uncomfortable. He went undrafted out of East Carolina in 2022, climbed from the practice squad, and became the defense’s most reliable big-play catalyst.
His overtime interception of Josh Allen in last January’s divisional-round win over Buffalo sent Denver to the AFC Championship Game. Eight months later he picked off Geno Smith in Seattle to swing a Week 6 victory. Few Broncos have authored more clutch moments in the past two seasons.
Source says haven't been serious contract discussions at this point between #Broncos & nickel back Ja'Quan McMillian, also in final year of deal. We shall see if this means Broncos have chosen to extend Riley Moss at this point over JMac with thinking they also have Jahdae Barron
Slot corners with that track record are commanding top-of-market money on the open market. The Broncos could still circle back — franchise-tag McMillian, match an offer sheet in March, or negotiate a late-season extension — but Thursday’s sequence suggests Moss was the priority. Broncos Wire noted that some fans believed McMillian’s durability and playmaking warranted the first new deal.
McMillian, born June 4, 2000, arrived in Denver as an undrafted free agent from East Carolina in 2022 after twice earning second-team all-AAC honors and a Jim Thorpe Award semifinalist nod in 2021. He spent his rookie year on the practice squad before making his first career start in Week 18 against the Los Angeles Chargers, playing every defensive snap.
In Week 13 of the 2024 season he intercepted Jameis Winston and returned it 44 yards for a touchdown to seal a win over Cleveland, and in Week 11 of the 2025 season he posted an interception and two sacks in a victory over Kansas City that moved the Broncos to 9–2 atop the AFC West.
The secondary is already one of the NFL’s most expensive. Surtain, Moss, and the pending McMillian decision represent a concentration of cap resources few teams attempt. Denver’s front office has eight regular-season games, and potentially a playoff run, to decide whether the undrafted star who saved their 2025 season fits the 2027 budget — or whether the first-round pick already on the roster makes him a luxury they can’t afford.
