“I’ve obeyed the rules my whole life. I don’t envisage lying on the street. I don’t envisage lying in front of bulldozers,” Philip Farrelly told The Irish Times in March.
The businessman, aged in his 70s, lodged a fresh planning and retention application with Fingal County Council on November 18 for the two-storey rear extension at his Victorian home on Burrow Road, Sutton, and for a proposed domestic garage with boundary fence amendments, The Irish Times reported. Third-party observations close on December 22.
Fingal County Council issued an enforcement order in March 2020 directing removal of the extension within four months after Farrelly demolished an earlier rear addition in 2019 and built a larger replacement without permission. The council waited until November 2024 to begin court proceedings, arguing the development was not exempt and citing a ruling by the former An Bord Pleanála, now An Coimisiún Pleanála, to that effect.
A Circuit Court judge ordered demolition by November 2 this year. Farrelly appealed to the High Court; the appeal has not been heard and the extension remains standing. He has said the €300,000 build was necessary because the original structure was “structurally unsound and unsafe” and that “there are hundreds of solutions” short of demolition, such as partial removal.
The extension now houses Farrelly and his wife, while their son and daughter-in-law occupy the rest of the house.
Farrelly declined to comment when contacted by The Irish Times on Sunday. The council’s delay of more than four years before seeking a court order has been a point of contention; Farrelly previously argued the case “was not an application that had been given any urgency.”