Carney and Shannon Vie for Maine Attorney General in Legislative Selection Race

State Sen. Anne Carney and lawyer Timothy Shannon are vying to be Maine’s next attorney general.

Unlike most states that popularly elect their top legal officer, Maine retains an 1820 constitutional provision giving the Legislature sole authority to select the attorney general, secretary of state, and state treasurer. While voters decided legislative races on Nov. 3, the final choice for attorney general rests entirely with lawmakers.

Both candidates are Democrats competing behind closed doors to win over legislators before the formal vote. Lawmakers will meet on Dec. 2 to get sworn in and select these constitutional positions, operating within a Legislature where Democrats hold larger majorities after the recent election.

Incumbent Attorney General Aaron Frey terms out at the end of the year. The next attorney general will direct major crime investigations and represent state agencies in court.

Carney brings legislative and legal experience to the contest. A Cape Elizabeth resident who has represented Cumberland County in the upper chamber since 2020, she practiced employment, civil rights, and municipal law for 17 years and later provided free legal representation to low-income Mainers as an in-house volunteer attorney for Pine Tree Legal Assistance.

Shannon brings 24 years of private practice experience as a trial and appellate lawyer representing high-tech companies and inventors. He previously ran for attorney general in 2018 when Frey was first selected for the role.

“I have been watching the office closely for eight years,” Shannon said. “I think what ultimately nudged me back into running again is I am not satisfied with the state of the law, our state or our country with respect to some fundamental problems.”

Both candidates identified standing up to President Donald Trump and protecting consumers as top priorities. Carney emphasized preventing financial scams from draining retirement savings from Mainers, while Shannon focused on establishing guardrails around artificial intelligence and addictive apps.

The contenders differ on how they would approach major state lawsuits. Shannon argued that Maine should pursue independent state-specific lawsuits alongside multi-state litigation, pointing to the New Mexico attorney general who won a $25 billion civil penalty against Meta. Carney, who oversees the Attorney General’s Office budget as chair of the Judiciary Committee, said she would evaluate whether to join multi-state actions or file individually based on efficiency and resource limits.

On tribal sovereignty, both Carney and Shannon support fully restoring rights to the Wabanaki Nations, diverging from Frey’s alignment with Gov. Janet Mills. Lawmakers will cast their formal votes on Dec. 2.