The Tallahassee City Commission fired City Manager Karen Jumonville on November 18 after seven weeks on the job, a move that could cost taxpayers nearly $2 million in severance, salary and legal fees, tallahassee.com reported.
Jumonville started October 1 under a five-year contract through September 2031 at $317,000 a year. The contract requires four votes to terminate her. Mayor Jeremy Matlow, Commissioner Jack Porter and Commissioner P.J. Perez voted to fire her anyway; Commissioners Curtis Richardson and Dianne Williams-Cox voted no.
City Attorney Amy Toman warned the commission that no court has settled whether the four-vote clause holds and that a breach-of-contract suit could follow. The contract guarantees 20 weeks of severance as a floor. If a court enforces the full term, the city owes nearly five more years of salary — about $1.5 million — plus retirement contributions, a car allowance and legal bills that could drag on for years, pushing the total toward $2 million.
“She gave this city 27 years. She got seven weeks,” Fincher Smith wrote in the opinion column published by tallahassee.com. Smith is a third-generation Tallahasseean and partner at Frog Realty and former developer who has spent over 25 years in Tallahassee’s housing market.
Richardson said he was “embarrassed by how it played out.”
Matlow and Porter had opposed Jumonville’s hiring in September and said so publicly. “That was a fair argument in September,” Smith wrote. “It is no reason to tear up a signed contract in November.”
Before the vote, the new majority floated keeping Jumonville as a consultant for three years to head off a lawsuit. It went nowhere.
The firing came five days after Florida voters passed Amendment 3, which raises the homestead exemption on non-school property taxes to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028 without sending cities revenue to cover the gap.
Every city in Florida is writing a leaner budget now.
By comparison, Florida State University fired football coach Mike Norvell on November 1 and took on a buyout of nearly $50 million. Norvell had six seasons to prove himself. Jumonville had seven weeks.
“And a football coach doesn’t run your water,” Smith wrote.
Matlow says people want a “cultural shift” in how the city engages with the community. The next commission meeting will test whether the new majority can advance that agenda without further legal exposure.