Colorado Buffaloes Eliminated From Bowl Eligibility After 35-28 Loss to Cincinnati

Colorado’s bowl hopes died at Nippert Stadium on Saturday, where a 35-28 loss to Cincinnati dropped the Buffaloes to 4-7 and ended any path to a sixth win, Colorado Buffaloes On SI reported.

The defeat completed a familiar script for Deion Sanders’ program: the offense found rhythm, throwing for 312 yards and three touchdowns behind Isaac Wilson, but three interceptions — including a final pick into double coverage with 33 seconds left — proved fatal. Cincinnati running back Cole Tabb gashed the Buffaloes for 230 all-purpose yards and four total touchdowns, exploiting a defense missing its starting safety and a hobbled interior lineman.

Wilson’s stat line looks respectable on paper — 312 yards, three scores — but the tape tells a different story. He stared down routes all afternoon, throwing into double, triple and even quadruple coverage.

His second interception came on a productive drive deep in Bearcats territory; the third sealed the game. Sports Yahoo framed it bluntly: Wilson cannot win when the game rides on his shoulders, and the program needs a significant upgrade at the position regardless of who coaches next season.

The Buffaloes managed only 121 rushing yards against a Cincinnati defense that entered the day as the conference’s Achilles’ heel. Richard Young, Colorado’s leading rusher, was held to 55 yards. When the run game stalled, Wilson tried to play hero ball — exactly the scenario offensive coordinator Brennan Marion warned against pregame.

Colorado Buffaloes Eliminated From Bowl Eligibility After 35-28 Loss to Cincinnati
Photo: sports.yahoo.com

Colorado took the field without starting safety Naeten Mitchell, cornerback Cree Thomas and tight end Corbin Laisure. Defensive lineman Dylan Manuel played through an apparent hand injury and wasn’t himself.

The absences cascaded: backup safety Ben Finneseth was targeted repeatedly by the Bearcats, and the interior defensive line couldn’t clog running lanes for Tabb. Even the missed 60-yard field goal before halftime traced to injuries — regular kicker Elliot Arnold wasn’t cleared to play, forcing Daniel Gerlach into a low-percentage attempt that fell short.

Colorado needs to acquire defensive linemen who can stop the run because the team has given up at least 200 rushing yards in each of its past two games.

The Buffaloes have now lost 10 straight Big 12 road games. Cincinnati, meanwhile, snapped a 12-game November losing streak dating to 2024 and secured its own bowl eligibility at 6-5.

Colorado football
Photo: thednvr.com

For the second year and third time in Sanders’ four seasons, Colorado will miss a bowl game. A loss to UCF next week would mark the third sub-.500 finish in his tenure. Sports Yahoo argued the $11 million contract carries expectations that six wins — or even bowl eligibility — should be the baseline, not the ceiling.

The counterpoint: many coaches before Sanders also failed to reach bowls in three of their first four seasons at Colorado. The program’s structural challenges — recruiting geography, roster turnover, conference realignment — predate his arrival. But the transfer portal era was supposed to accelerate rebuilds.

Colorado enters the offseason needing defensive linemen who can stop the run, a quarterback who protects the football, and a decision on whether the head coach gets a fifth year to prove the model works.

Next Saturday against UCF in Boulder, the Buffaloes play for pride and a 5-7 finish. The bowl conversation is over. The coaching conversation is just beginning.