Indianapolis Colts owner Jim Irsay fired general manager Chris Ballard in Week 6 but kept head coach Shane Steichen, a decision Horseshoe Heroes reported has left the franchise drifting toward a lost season with no first-round pick to show for it.
Steichen guided the team to an 8-2 start in 2025 before the bottom fell out. The now-infamous Sauce Gardner trade — which sent premium draft capital to New York for a cornerback who has yet to replicate his All-Pro form — accelerated the pressure on the entire front office. Ballard paid the price. Steichen did not.
“He looks like someone who knows he won’t be back next season,” the Horseshoe Heroes analysis said, describing a sideline demeanor that has shifted from intense to resigned over the past month. The Colts have hovered around .500 with a revolving door at quarterback, but the offensive identity Steichen was hired to build has evaporated.

Reggie Wayne has been in the building since the Frank Reich regime. The six-time Pro Bowler and Super Bowl XLI champion holds franchise records for regular-season games played (211), wins (143), postseason receptions (93), playoff receiving yards (1,254) and playoff touchdown catches (nine). He has overseen the development of Alec Pierce, Josh Downs and Michael Pittman Jr. as wide receivers coach.
That resume does not automatically translate to head-coaching readiness. The Jeff Saturday experiment in 2022 proved that franchise legends can struggle when elevated without preparatory experience. But Wayne has survived two regime changes, commands the locker room, and cannot produce results materially worse than the current trajectory.
The Colts do not control their own first-round pick in the upcoming draft, removing the usual incentive to protect draft position. Two months of Wayne leading the program would at minimum clarify whether he warrants a formal interview in the next hiring cycle. If he falters, the search starts earlier with live data rather than speculation.

Steichen will likely land an offensive coordinator role in 2027 or 2028; his schematic mind remains respected league-wide. Head-coaching authority — game management, locker-room command, situational awareness — has not materialized in nearly two full seasons.
Irsay has historically moved slowly on coaching changes, preferring to let seasons play out. That patience cost the Colts a head start on the 2023 cycle after Frank Reich’s dismissal. The same hesitation now burns weeks that could belong to evaluation.