Columbus Crew beat Inter Miami 3-0 in Game 1 of their best-of-three MLS first-round playoff series on Saturday at Nu Stadium, and the match turned on a first-half stoppage-time throw-in that Lionel Messi hurled into the face of Gonzalo Tapia. Referee Allen Chapman showed both players yellow cards, but Crew head coach Laurent Courtois said the incident warranted a red card and a suspension for Miami’s star forward.
What happened on the throw-in
Columbus Crew beat Inter Miami 3-0 in a playoff opener as Tapia scored twice and Taha Habroune added a goal.
With Columbus leading 1-0 in first-half stoppage time, Messi took a quick throw-in from a couple of feet away and struck Tapia in the face. Tapia had not retreated the required two yards. The forward fell to the ground before getting up to argue with Messi. Chapman cautioned both players.
Why Courtois says it was a red-card offense
“Everyone knows that was more than a yellow card,” Courtois told reporters after the match. He added that the entire situation is “sad,” when asked if Major League Soccer should review the incident. A red card would have suspended Messi for at least Game 2, with Miami facing elimination.
Lionel Messi drilled Gonzalo Tapia in the head with this throw-in pic.twitter.com/TEwPTFvMSK
How Chapman explained the decision
“The force used was negligible and the offense did not reach the level of violent conduct,” Chapman told a pool reporter, according to The Guardian.
What the players and Miami staff said
“It's a play in the match. I don't know if it's a red card, but I am not the referee to say,” Tapia said. “It stays there.”
Inter Miami coach Cristian “Kily” González downplayed the call. “I have to think about the situation, the card doesn’t change much. The referee saw a yellow and that is it, we can’t blame the referee. Sometimes they make mistakes, sometimes they don’t like each one of us and we have to accept it,” said Kily Gonzalez, Inter Miami coach.
Miami midfielder Casemiro acknowledged the stakes. “Pressure? Of course there is pressure. Inter Miami always plays to win and we know if we lose the next game we are out. The most important thing now is to be calm. We know we have to do better, because we can do better. We were second on the table and so the next game we’ll use it to show the rest how strong we are,” said Casemiro, Miami midfielder.
Crew beat Miami 3-0 in opener
Miami, the defending champions and second seed in the Eastern Conference, must win Game 2 in Columbus on Friday to force a decisive third match back at Nu Stadium.
Crew claim Miami played with 10 men before incident
Columbus head coach Laurent Courtois said Miami had already been reduced to 10 men when Messi threw the ball at Tapia in first-half stoppage time, The Guardian reported.
González frames loss as character test
Inter Miami coach Cristian “Kily” González said after the match that nothing went right for his side and they effectively created Columbus’s chances, The Guardian reported. He added that the team must learn from the performance because a loss in Game 2 would end their season.
González described the situation as the best possible challenge for the group and said he knows his players have the character to respond, according to The Guardian.
Before taking the Columbus Crew job on an interim basis in 2025, Laurent Courtois spent 2022–2024 as head coach of Columbus Crew 2, winning the inaugural MLS Next Pro title and earning Coach of the Year honors. He then served as head coach of CF Montréal from January 2024 until March 2025, guiding the club to an eighth-place Eastern Conference finish and a playoff berth before a five-game winless start led to his dismissal.
Messi’s regular-season form
Before kickoff, co-owner Jorge Mas presented Messi with the 2026 Golden Boot. He led the league with 26 goals and tied for the most assists with 17 in 31 appearances, becoming the first player to win the award in consecutive seasons, ESPN reported. He is also expected to claim a third straight MLS MVP award.
Related reading