Columnist Urges 19-Year-Old to End Nine-Month Relationship Lacking Romance

In a column for The Boston Globe, Meredith Goldstein argues that a 19-year-old letter writer should end a nine-month relationship because the romance they hope for has not arrived and likely will not.

The writer, who identifies only as “Heavy Weight,” tells Goldstein they care deeply for their partner and could imagine a shared life, but feel uncertain whether the connection is truly romantic or sexual in the way the partner needs.

They also want to move abroad and fear losing the comfort the relationship provides. Goldstein responds that the letter itself functions as a breakup speech and urges the writer to share those generous words directly with their partner.

Readers responding to the column overwhelmingly agreed. One commenter, Penseuse, wrote that nine months is more than enough time to develop romantic feelings and warned against staying in situations out of fear of change.

“You are going to have to do that over and over again in your life with dating, job searching, and starting over in a new city if you move,” Penseuse wrote. “Don’t be a person who stays in situations that aren’t right for you because you’re afraid of making a change and putting yourself out there.”

Another reader, DDL314, described the corrosive effect of staying in a lopsided dynamic. “Being in a relationship where you just feel lukewarm at best and they are earnestly loving you up gets incredibly uncomfortable,” they wrote.

“It starts to mess with your head, your identity, and your sense of justice toward the other person. Eventually you feel a particularly awful kind of loneliness but without any of the benefits of actually being single. Resentment grows like mold.”

Columnist Urges 19-Year-Old to End Nine-Month Relationship Lacking Romance

Library Queen added bluntly: “Nine months is more than enough time for you to know what you don’t feel. In fact, you’re overdue. Now get out there and find it. Have a blast abroad.”

Goldstein launched the “Love Letters” column in 2009 and has expanded it into a podcast featuring real people sharing relationship stories. She published a memoir, “Can’t Help Myself: Lessons and Confessions From a Modern Advice Columnist,” in 2018, along with young adult novels including “Chemistry Lessons” and “Things That Grow.” Born in New Jersey and raised in Highland, Maryland, she graduated from Syracuse University and now lives in Jamaica Plain, Massachusetts.

The column appears in the Globe’s “Love Letters” section, which invites readers to send relationship questions to [email protected] or through an online form. New episodes of Goldstein’s “Love Letters” podcast are available on major platforms.