Consumer NZ: Briscoes Clearest on Sale Prices, Noel Leeming Worst in 12‑Week Check

Consumer NZ tracked 13 products across five major retailers for 12 weeks and found promotional labels routinely detached from actual value, 1News reported.

The watchdog ranked Briscoes first for pricing clarity, noting its sale prices were generally cheaper than usual prices and prices regularly returned to full price between promotions. Farmers placed second, but a washing machine carried a “great price” label for the entire 12-week period while its price swung from $1,248 to $1,669. JB Hi-Fi advertised a Breville Barista Express as “On Sale” at $600, then weeks later labeled the same machine a “Red Hot Deal” at $698 and $848.

Harvey Norman reduced promotional label use after last year’s criticism, yet a garment steamer was $34 cheaper without a “hot deal” tag and an air fryer $10 cheaper without a “birthday deal” label. Noel Leeming ranked last, advertising a Breville coffee machine as a “Mega Deal” at $869 — the highest price Consumer NZ recorded for that product during the study.

“There may be a discount, but it’s not perhaps as good as consumers are led to believe,” Consumer NZ research lead Rebecca Styles told 1News. She said retailers risked breaching the Fair Trading Act if customers were misled.

Noel Leeming chief executive Jason Bell rejected the breach allegation. “We are confident this is not a breach of the Fair Trading Act or misleading, as it was just positioned as a deal, we did not claim a specific saving,” Bell told 1News. Other retailers had not yet responded to questions from 1News.

Briscoes Sets Baseline While Noel Leeming Anchors Bottom

Consumer NZ’s methodology created a clear hierarchy. Briscoes earned the top ranking because its prices “don’t fluctuate as much,” Styles told 1News, and the chain used less promotional language than competitors. That transparency did not guarantee the lowest absolute price: a Ninja air fryer dropped to $125 at Briscoes but later hit $97 at Noel Leeming.

Farmers’ “great price” labels appeared persistent rather than promotional. The same Samsung heat-pump dryer wore the label at both $1,399 and $1,989. JB Hi-Fi’s tiered language — “On Sale” at $600, “Red Hot Deal” at $698 and $848 — gave shoppers “little indication of how much shoppers were actually saving,” Consumer NZ found.

Harvey Norman Adjusts Labels, Not Necessarily Prices

Harvey Norman cut back on promotional labels after Consumer NZ’s previous investigation, the watchdog said. Yet the labeling that remained still flagged prices higher than unpromoted alternatives. A handheld garment steamer cost $34 less when it carried no “hot deal” badge; an air fryer was $10 cheaper without “birthday deal” or “hot deal” tags. Styles told 1News that constant promotions obscure what a product’s normal price actually is.

Noel Leeming’s “Mega Deal” Hits Study High

The most striking divergence appeared at Noel Leeming. The Breville coffee machine tagged “Mega Deal” at $869 represented the peak price in the 12-week window. “The mega deal was actually a meagre deal,” Styles told 1News. Bell countered that the machine “regularly featured in promotions and that the ‘Mega Deal’ price was still among the best available on the market at the time,” according to 1News.

Consumer NZ Urges Independent Price Tracking

Styles advised against relying on sales pitch language. “One thing consumers can do is actually track the prices of things they’ve got their eye on,” she told 1News.

The watchdog recommends price-tracking tools and cross-retailer comparison before purchase, and cautioned that major events like Black Friday do not automatically deliver the year’s lowest prices. “Sometimes the language doesn’t actually match the level of saving that people are getting,” Styles told 1News.

Consumer NZ, the independent non-profit watchdog behind the retailer pricing study, traces its roots to the Consumers’ Council founded in 1959. It lost government funding in 1986, became a member-funded incorporated society in 1989, and adopted its current name in 2007.

The organisation is known for its quarterly magazine Consumer and for managing Powerswitch, a site that helps households compare electricity plans. Its campaigns have targeted supermarket pricing, airline passenger rights and bank responsibilities for scam victims, and its research underpins the Fair Trading Act scrutiny applied in this investigation.

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and market analysis purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, or legal advice. Always consult with a certified financial professional before making investment decisions.