Court Dismisses JPMorgan Lawsuit, Richmond Can Pursue False Claims Act Suit

A prior antitrust settlement does not bar the City of Richmond, California, from pursuing fraud claims involving federally taxable interest rate swaps, a federal court ruled on Tuesday.

According to [vitallaw.com], U.S. District Judge Victor Marrero of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York dismissed a lawsuit brought by JPMorgan Chase & Co. that sought to enforce a 2015 antitrust agreement against the municipality.

The earlier multidistrict litigation resolved price-fixing and bid-rigging claims in the municipal derivatives market, but the court found those terms did not cover Richmond’s subsequent actions under the California False Claims Act.

The dispute stems from interest rate swaps entered into in 2007 with Bear Stearns, an institution later acquired by JPMorgan. In March 2025, Richmond filed a separate action against JPMorgan and the Royal Bank of Canada, alleging that swaps associated with its Series 2005 Pension Obligation Bonds failed statutory rating requirements and were fraudulently induced.

Tax Status Defines Settlement Scope

The central question before the court involved the exact definition of covered transactions within the 2015 settlement agreement. The agreement released claims arising from municipal derivatives associated with debt exempt from both federal and state taxes.

Richmond’s pension obligation bonds were exempt from state taxes but remained federally taxable. Applying New York contract law, the court concluded that the undefined term “tax-exempt” carried its ordinary meaning and could not expand to encompass federally taxable debt.

JPMorgan argued that the settlement incorporated broader claims and transactions raised by other settling municipalities, such as Stockton and Riverside. The court rejected this interpretation, noting that incorporation by reference requires specific contractual language identifying the documents and communicating a clear intent to incorporate their contents.

Unrelated Conduct and Fraud Allegations

The court emphasized that the 2015 agreement targeted an industry-wide antitrust conspiracy to rig bids and fix prices in municipal derivatives. Richmond’s newer claims, by contrast, center on allegations of fraudulent inducement, false certification, and material omissions regarding pension obligation bond swaps.

“The settlement could not reasonably be interpreted as releasing claims of fraudulent inducement and false certification unrelated to the earlier antitrust allegations,” the court said in its ruling.

Beth Deborah Newton of Sullivan & Cromwell, LLP represented JPMorgan Chase & Co., while Matthew Melamed of Keller Rohrback L.L.P. represented the City of Richmond in Case No. 1:26-cv-01143-VM.

The dismissal clears the path for Richmond’s California FalseClaims Act lawsuit to proceed independently without interference from the decade-old antitrust resolution.