Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne announced Thursday that Madison Officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson will not face criminal charges in the July 22 shooting death of Corey Ruiz, a decision the prosecutor said rests on Wisconsin’s self-defense statute applying equally to police and civilians.
The ruling closes a nearly four-month investigation by the Wisconsin Department of Justice Division of Criminal Investigation, which produced a nearly 1,800-page file Ozanne reviewed alongside squad camera video, cellphone footage, scene diagrams and officer interviews, according to WMTV. Ozanne met privately with Ruiz’s family Thursday morning before making the announcement public.
“Mr. Ruiz’s death is and was a tragedy,” Ozanne said. “I have met privately with his family and offered my condolences, and I publicly extend my sympathies to his family, friends and community who continue to grieve his loss.”
Four officers responded to the Marquette neighborhood the afternoon of Wednesday, July 22, after someone reported a person checking parked vehicles in an alleged burglary attempt. The man, later identified as Ruiz, fled on a bicycle.
Officers located him roughly 30 minutes later at the intersection of South Baldwin and Williamson Streets. An officer exited his squad car and spoke to Ruiz as he rode past on the sidewalk; Ruiz lost control and fell off the bike into the intersection.
The officer repeatedly told Ruiz to “get your hands behind your back, quit reaching in your waist” while trying to take him into custody, Ozanne said. Two other officers joined to bring Ruiz’s arms behind his back.
Ozanne said Ruiz pulled a knife with his right hand and continued to struggle. Baitinger-Peterson told state investigators he grabbed Ruiz’s wrist, felt pain, saw the knife and realized he had been cut. He said he could not control Ruiz’s hand and feared he or another officer would be stabbed.
Two officers deployed Tasers. One set of probes attached to Ruiz’s left hand, the other to his left side, according to the DCI report. An Axon expert told investigators both Tasers were fired at close range — too close for the probes to spread far enough to incapacitate Ruiz effectively, WMTV reported.
One Taser activated for about three seconds before the safety was switched to a powered-down position, ending the cycle early. Madison Police Department policy generally discourages simultaneous Taser applications but allows them when an officer reasonably believes the need for control or lack of alternatives outweighs the risk. The DCI records do not establish whether both devices delivered current through Ruiz or whether their electrical outputs overlapped.
Ruiz fell or was taken to the ground before Baitinger-Peterson fired three shots, Ozanne said. Firefighters and EMS attempted life-saving measures and transported Ruiz to a hospital, where he died.
The autopsy showed Ruiz was shot once in the torso and once in the head. Toxicology results showed Ruiz had cocaine and methamphetamine in his system, though the report does not say whether those substances caused the Tasers to be ineffective.

“Under Wisconsin law, which applies equally to members of law enforcement and to those who are not, any person may use deadly force to respond to a genuine fear of deadly force to that person or any other person,” Ozanne’s statement read.
“This critical incident involved City of Madison police officers who were attempting the apprehension of an individual wanted for attempted burglary of an occupied home, who was actively evading police, and when contact was made physically resisted, produced a weapon, and appeared to be unphased by two less than lethal devices used by officers,” Ozanne said.
Baitinger-Peterson has more than a decade of law enforcement experience, WMTV noted. The Madison Police Department did not use body cameras at the time of the incident but has since pledged to start a body camera program.
LIVE: A Dane County prosecutor has declined to charge a Madison police officer who shot and killed Corey Ruiz. His family and civil rights attorney Ben Crump are speaking after the decision. https://t.co/CJFwqqzeE0
More on Corey Ruiz
Dane County’s district attorney spoke out on Friday asking the public for patience over a week after a Madison police officer shot and killed Corey Ruiz. https://t.co/ZRLzQ5ry1D
In his decision, the district attorney said the shooting was legally justified because Corey Ruiz resisted arrest, pulled a knife and appeared unaffected by two Taser deployments. https://t.co/mQyYz7dyFs pic.twitter.com/SkcBqWsRb7
JUST IN: The Madison police officer who shot and killed 38-year-old Corey Ruiz in July will not be charged in his death. https://t.co/PB7I1h2Eg9