“We are extremely disappointed,” ChristianaCare CEO Jenn Schwartz said Tuesday after the Delaware Health Resources Board voted down the system’s two proposed microhospitals in Kent and Sussex counties.
The board’s rejection caps a months-long fight that pitted the state’s largest health system against three rival hospital networks — Bayhealth, Beebe Healthcare and TidalHealth — over whether southern Delaware needs new inpatient beds or simply more primary care. ChristianaCare had sought to spend more than $123 million on the campuses in Camden and Georgetown, partnering with for-profit operator Emerus Holdings.
Bayhealth President and CEO Terry Murphy called the decision the right one for affordability. “We believe improving healthcare access requires balancing access, quality and affordability,” Murphy said in a statement. “Bayhealth welcomes competition and supports expanding outpatient services, but we do not believe adding small hospitals is the best approach for our communities.”
Beebe Healthcare President and CEO David Tam agreed. “Sussex County is growing and aging, creating greater demand for both routine and increasingly complex care,” Tam said. “Greater access to primary and specialty care, stronger community-based services, and continued investment in the healthcare workforce remain priorities for Beebe as we build the healthcare capacity Sussex County needs for the long term.”
The proposed Camden campus would sit roughly four miles from Bayhealth’s Kent County campus. The Georgetown site would land about ten miles from Bayhealth’s Milton location, thirteen miles from TidalHealth Nanticoke in Seaford and sixteen miles from Beebe’s Lewes hospital, WHYY reported. All three existing providers already operate emergency beds in those corridors.
Opposition formalized in August when Bayhealth sent a letter to the board, followed by TidalHealth and Beebe. Each argued the applications failed to prove a genuine need for additional inpatient beds, pointing instead to a shortage of primary care providers.
“We welcome the competition in all industries. Competition makes you better,” Bayhealth Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer Kyle Benoit said during the October public hearing. “To us, it came down to what is the right level of competition, what truly is needed.”
Board members pressed ChristianaCare on transportation agreements, potential treatment delays and what they viewed as discrepancies between the initial application and testimony at the hearing.
John Hundley, chief operating officer at Westside Family Healthcare, zeroed in on volume projections he read as showing the Camden facility expecting 3.6 million visits a year in a county with fewer than 200,000 residents. ChristianaCare representatives said those figures were not correct and were not intended to be interpreted that way.
The ownership structure also drew scrutiny. ChristianaCare said it would be the sole owner and operator of the health centers and would retain majority ownership of the microhospitals themselves. Rivals questioned how the hybrid model — nonprofit system partnered with a for-profit management company — would be defined or governed by the state.
A TidalHealth spokesperson framed the core disagreement this way: “We believe healthcare investments should focus on keeping people healthy and out of the hospital, rather than adding duplicative inpatient hospital infrastructure that could increase the overall cost of care without addressing these fundamental needs.”
Schwartz said ChristianaCare would “carefully review the decision and evaluate our options.” The system had previously told the board it would only move forward if both campuses were approved together, a condition that gave some members pause about approving one without the other. For now, the county lines that have long defined Delaware’s hospital territories remain intact.
- Red Sox Acquire Nick Fortes From Rays for Angel Roa, DFA Connor Wong
- Ravens’ Marlon Humphrey Apologizes for ‘Best at Making Criminals’ Podcast Remark, Mayor Rebukes Apology
- South Korean Welfare Committee Increases Budget to Provide Oral Health Screenings for Seniors on Medical Aid (world-today-news.com)
- GMB to ballot Northern Ireland health workers over possible Christmas strike (newsarchyuk.com)