East Providence police denied a resident access to audit logs for the city’s automated license plate reader system, while admitting the original agreements governing how that data is shared with more than a dozen other agencies were lost during a headquarters renovation.
The revelations emerged Tuesday night at the City Council meeting, where Riverside resident John Renquinha detailed the results of Access to Public Records Act requests he filed in October, EastBayRI.com reported. The city’s five-year, $297,000 contract with Flock Safety, approved in May 2023, was sold as a force multiplier linked to surrounding departments. What Renquinha found instead was a paper trail with critical gaps.
Renquinha asked for three things: the Flock database search logs from early September through early October, the department’s written policies for officer training on the system, and the memoranda of understanding governing data sharing with other agencies. He received the training policies. The other two requests hit a wall — for entirely different reasons.
The audit logs the public cannot see
The department refused to release the audit logs, citing an APRA exemption for records pertaining to active criminal investigations. Those logs would show every license plate searched, the stated reason for the search, and the identity of the officer who ran it. Without them, there is no public mechanism to detect patterns — like one officer repeatedly querying the same plate over months.

“The people deserve to know if there’s one police officer repeatedly searching for one person throughout the month, throughout the six months, throughout the year. That’s how the people can find out about Flock abuse,”
McMullen pointed to New Bedford, Massachusetts, where audit logs recently revealed officers tracking partners and ex-girlfriends. “Without that, the police are saying ‘Give us a surveillance database, and you don’t get to know how we use it at all. Just trust us.’ And we see across the country that trust has been abused,” Renquinha said.
Lost MOUs and a missing procurement record
The missing memoranda of understanding are a separate failure. Police Chief Michael Rapoza confirmed the original MOUs — spelling out which agencies could access East Providence data and which cameras the city could tap — were lost during recent headquarters upgrades. Physical and digital copies both vanished.
“We’ve made a concerted effort to try and locate those originals but unfortunately we were not successful,” Rapoza said. He argued the loss is moot because the department has since adopted a standardized statewide MOU template developed by the Rhode Island Police Chiefs Association, complete with signed agreements from every current partner.

That partner list is long: Central Falls, Cranston, Cumberland, Fall River, the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children, Newport, North Providence, Pawtucket, Providence, Rhode Island State Police, Seekonk, Smithfield, Somerset, Tiverton, Warwick, West Greenwich, and Woonsocket. The new MOU bars “daisy-chaining” — Barrington cannot ask East Providence for Cranston’s data — and Rapoza said the city shares nothing with ICE or Border Patrol.
Renquinha, who serves as Barrington’s DPW director and knows procurement law, also asked for bid specifications, vendor proposals, or a sole-source declaration letter justifying Flock as the only viable vendor. City Solicitor Michael Marcello replied on October 29 that no such documents exist. Renquinha said Warwick, East Greenwich, Providence, and Pawtucket all filed declaration letters for their Flock contracts. East Providence did not.
“You’re supposed to file a declaration letter when you have a bid on a contract like that,” Renquinha said. “When you do that, it’s basically that you want to be a part of the club. You want to get into their little cameras and they want to get into your little cameras… All being part of the club, but you’re supposed to still follow state law.”
City hall’s defense
Mayor Bob DaSilva acknowledged the missing sole-source letter may have been a “step that we missed.” He said former Chief Christopher Francesconi brought the Flock proposal in 2023 because East Providence was an outlier — surrounded by communities already on the network — and risked becoming a soft target for criminals avoiding tracked jurisdictions. The contract passed the City Council.
DaSilva dismissed the idea of canceling the program, pointing to Providence’s move toward ending its own ALPR contract. “That’s going to be interesting to see what happens with the crime rate,” he said. “We’re not interested in getting rid of it here in East Providence.”
Flock Safety, founded in 2017 by three Georgia Tech alumni who built their first cameras by hand around a dining room table, now operates in all 50 states and performs over 20 billion vehicle scans monthly.
The company, valued at $7.5 billion after raising $950 million in venture funding, has faced increasing legal scrutiny; a Virginia judge ruled in June 2024 that its ALPR data collection constitutes a search under the Fourth Amendment requiring a warrant, and several cities have ended contracts over privacy and immigration-enforcement concerns.
Rapoza, speaking from a New England Association of Chiefs of Police conference, said ALPR policy has become the dominant topic in law enforcement circles. He expects a wave of legislative action when the General Assembly reconvenes in January. For now, the city has updated its Flock transparency portal to list the current data-sharing partners — a step taken after EastBayRI.com’s inquiries.