Eastern Illinois Edges Charleston Southern 20-17 in Overtime to Snap Skid

Eastern Illinois snapped a losing skid to close the 2026 season with a 20-17 overtime victory over Charleston Southern on Saturday, handing the Buccaneers their fifth one-score defeat of the year.

The Panthers (4-8, 3-4 OVC) survived a chaotic afternoon at O’Brien Field where Charleston Southern (4-8, 1-6 OVC) operated almost exclusively out of a single-wing formation, rushing for 271 yards while attempting just 24 yards passing, according to the Post and Courier. Eastern Illinois University Athletics reported the game-winning sequence began with a 27-yard field goal on the first overtime possession, followed by a missed tying attempt by the Buccaneers.

The backup quarterback spark

Eastern Illinois went to the second half with backup Jeremiah Salem under center. He authored the go-ahead touchdown drive late in the third quarter, capping it with a 21-yard strike to Eli Evans that put the Panthers up 14-10. The drive was kept alive by a crucial unsportsmanlike conduct penalty on Charleston Southern’s Austin Brown that turned a fourth-and-six into a first down at the EIU 46, per the official play-by-play.

Bucky logo, CSU
Photo: postandcourier.com

Salem finished the scoring drive 4-for-4 through the air, hitting Evans twice — including the touchdown — and finding Devin Whitlock and Charles Kellom for first downs. Drew Schiller’s extra point made it a four-point game with 2:37 left in the third.

Watters’ historic day in a losing cause

Charleston Southern’s Hakeem Watters rushed for 171 yards and scored on runs of 73 and 72 yards, the Post and Courier reported. His first touchdown came in the opening minute of the game, staking the Buccaneers to a 7-0 lead. Matt Rolader’s field goal extended it to 10-0 at halftime.

FB Postgame – Eastern Illinois (11/21/2026) — Charleston Southern Buccaneers

Watters struck again to end the third quarter, his second long touchdown run tying the game at 17. Eastern Illinois answered with a field goal to force overtime.

“What a battle. We’re not going to hang our heads for one second about our effort and execution. We played today with one arm tied behind our back, but our guys didn’t make excuses. They gave themselves opportunities to win. They played with great belief and resiliency. I can’t say enough about their character. We still hurt. It hurts deeply, but I’m proud to be their coach.”

— Gabe Giardina, Charleston Southern head coach, via Post and Courier

Third-down futility defines the season

The Buccaneers converted just one of 13 third-down attempts Saturday, a microcosm of a season defined by close margins. Five of Charleston Southern’s eight losses came by a single score, the Post and Courier noted. The team closed the year without a healthy, experienced quarterback, forcing the radical schematic shift to the single-wing.

Eastern Illinois, meanwhile, finishes .500 in conference play after starting the year 0-4. The Panthers’ three conference wins all came in the second half of the schedule.

Eastern Illinois University, founded in 1895 as a normal school to train teachers for East Central Illinois, became a university in 1957. Its original campus building, Old Main, is one of five “Altgeld’s castles” constructed in the 1890s under Governor John Peter Altgeld.

Charleston Southern’s missed field goal in overtime ended the 2026 campaign.