ESPN FPI Favors Ohio State 71.3%, SP+ Projects Tight 26-21 Win

ESPN analytics give Ohio State a 71.3 percent chance to beat Nebraska in Lincoln on Saturday, but the SP+ model sees a much tighter game, projecting a 26–21 final score and a 62 percent win probability for the Buckeyes. The discrepancy highlights the uncertainty surrounding freshman quarterback Luke Fahey’s second road start as Ohio State, ranked No. 14 in the latest College Football Playoff rankings, tries to keep its playoff hopes alive.

SP+ projects Ohio State to beat Nebraska 26-21 with a 62 percent win probability.

Ohio State enters the weekend at No. 14 in the third CFP release, six spots higher than a week ago and three spots outside the 12-team field. A win over the Cornhuskers at noon ET on Fox would set up a regular-season finale against Michigan with playoff implications few expected after back-to-back losses to USC and Oregon dropped the Buckeyes to 0–2 without injured starter Julian Sayin.

Why the models disagree on Saturday

The ESPN Football Power Index, which updates only after game results, locks the Buckeyes in as a 71.3 percent favorite. That number matches the confidence the model showed before the losses to the Trojans and Ducks — games Ohio State entered as a significant favorite but lost by a combined 33 points.

Yahoo Sports noted the recent history: “this same model had the Buckeyes with a significant chance of beating the Trojans on the road, and then the Ducks at home, and neither of those turned out so well.”

Bill Connelly’s SP+ model, which measures “the most sustainable and predictable aspects of football” rather than résumé strength, paints a different picture. It projects Ohio State 26, Nebraska 21 and assigns the Buckeyes a 62 percent win probability. Connelly told AOL.com the game “is going to be a tight game” with “all the variables and unknowns at play here.”

What the numbers say about each roster

SP+ ranks Ohio State No. 4 nationally with a 24.1 overall rating, trailing only Georgia (32.7), Notre Dame (25.6) and Miami (24.4). The Buckeyes grade out at 37.4 on offense (No. 10) and 13.4 on defense (No. 8), but special teams have slipped to a 0.1 rating (No. 64).

ESPN FPI Favors Ohio State 71.3%, SP+ Projects Tight 26-21 Win
Photo: aol.com

Nebraska sits at No. 18 with a 16.8 overall rating. The Cornhuskers own a 30.5 offensive rating (No. 40), a 13.5 defensive rating (No. 9) and a minus-0.3 special teams rating (No. 95). Matt Rhule’s squad has played its way into a respectable defensive profile that could test Fahey in his fourth career start.

Metric Ohio State Nebraska
SP+ Overall Rank No. 4 (24.1) No. 18 (16.8)
Offense Rating 37.4 (No. 10) 30.5 (No. 40)
Defense Rating 13.4 (No. 8) 13.5 (No. 9)
Special Teams Rating 0.1 (No. 64) -0.3 (No. 95)

The freshman quarterback variable

Fahey has steadied the ship since the Oregon loss, leading a 28–19 win over Northwestern last week at home. Saturday marks his second true road start, and the Buckeyes’ offensive line and running game will need to insulate him from a Nebraska defense that SP+ rates nearly identically to Ohio State’s own unit.

“It may come down to how Luke Fahey plays in his fourth start and second one away from home as the X factor in this one,” Connelly wrote.

The Buckeyes also need cleaner operation. Mental mistakes and undisciplined play characterized the two losses, and the coaching staff has emphasized execution over scheme adjustments this week. A turnover-free afternoon from Fahey would go a long way toward validating the FPI’s higher confidence.

Winning out secures playoff control for Buckeyes

Winning out puts Ohio State at 10–2 with a victory over Michigan in Columbus to close the regular season. The selection committee’s No. 14 ranking suggests the Buckeyes control their destiny if they can handle the next two weeks. The Cornhuskers represent the first hurdle; kickoff is set for noon ET Saturday at Ohio Stadium in Columbus, televised on Fox with Gus Johnson, Joel Klatt and Jenny Taft on the call.

“Hopefully, we are setting the stage for ‘The Game’ with some things on the line,” Buckeyes Wire wrote in its preview.