Ex-NYPD Cop Admits Killing Brooklyn Jogger: “Allah Told Me to Kill a Person”

  • Mohassib confessed to stabbing Suarez twice in the neck on a Bath Beach promenade.
  • He told The Post he retrieved a knife after work, killed her, then returned home and cleaned up.
  • The ex-Marine and former paraprofessional has a documented history of mental instability.
  • He is charged with second-degree murder and due in court Dec. 4.

Mohassib spoke to New York Post reporters Khristina Narizhnaya and Gabrielle Fahmy for less than five minutes at Rikers Island, invoking Allah’s name five times. “Allah told me to kill a person, so I killed her, the jogger Katie Suarez,” he said, his jumpsuit unbuttoned to reveal tattoos referencing Allah, a tiger and a shark.

“I didn’t know her, she was just there.”

“Two days before it happened, Allah told me I had to kill a person,” Mohassib added. “Allah told me to do it, so I did it.” He said he never questioned the order.

Ex-NYPD officer Sayed Mohassib admits to killing Brooklyn jogger Katie Suarez, says he acted on ‘div — UM LEGACY PRESS LTD

When asked if he had a message for Suarez’s family, he replied, “No. Allah told me to do it.” He then trailed off — “There was a little blood …” — and abruptly ended the interview.

Contradicting his earlier account

Mohassib initially told detectives he had blacked out and woke up covered in blood with the murder weapon in hand. To The Post, he described a deliberate sequence: “I got home from work, I got the knife, and I killed her…. I went home, I cleaned up.”

He also acknowledged lying at first. “At first I said that I didn’t do it, but now I’m saying that I did it because Allah told me to,” Mohassib said.

Police said Mohassib told them he discarded the knife in the garbage; investigators believe the unrecovered weapon may have reached a New Jersey landfill, LifeZette reported.

A trail of missed warnings

Mohassib worked for the NYPD for only six weeks in 2022 before leaving to enlist in the Marines, who discharged him after deeming him psychologically unfit. His attempt to rejoin the NYPD three months later was denied after he appeared at a precinct disheveled and erratic; he was transported to Bellevue Hospital that same day, Pulptastic reported.

Photo: gellerreport.com

He then returned to the Department of Education as a paraprofessional at PS 200 in Bath Beach. After the killing, colleagues noticed him talking to himself, speaking incoherently and acting erratically.

His family had previously called 911 after he threatened to “chop them up,” according to sources cited by the Post. Neighbors said he changed roughly three years ago after a vacation to Egypt. “He came back different. I don’t know what happened,” one neighbor told the Post.

The mosque he attended, the Muslim American Society Youth Center, had hosted a radical imam who preached warfare against Jews and opposition to the U.S. government, the Post reported.

Former NYPD Officer Sayed Mohassib Arrested in Jogger Katie Suarez's Stabbing — Oxygen

Charges and next steps

Mohassib is charged with second-degree murder, tampering with physical evidence and criminal possession of a weapon. He was arrested at his Bensonhurst home on Nov. 7 and is next due in court Dec. 4.