Fargo Veteran Speaks After Judge Dismisses Street Fair Gun Case

Owen Stish, a 27-year-old veteran, is speaking publicly for the first time since a federal judge dismissed the firearms case that put him in jail for two months after he openly carried an Anderson Arms 15 in a pistol configuration at the Fargo Street Fair in July, Valley News Live reported.

The dismissal, granted Monday by Magistrate Judge Alice Senechal, came after prosecutors moved to drop the remaining charge — possession of an unregistered firearm — following a Texas court ruling that invalidated the National Firearms Act registration requirement at the center of the case, the Forum reported.

Stish maintains he was legally carrying an unloaded handgun under North Dakota open-carry law and that a paperwork error from a long-vacated 2018 guardianship wrongly flagged him as a prohibited person.

The street fair encounter

Fargo police approached Stish at the downtown street fair on July 16 after attendees expressed concern about the Anderson Arms 15 in a pistol configuration he was carrying openly and unloaded, he told Valley News Live.

Officers asked him to put it away; he complied and left without arrest. The next day, police arrested him at a Dollar Tree store before his shift, citing a federal prohibition tied to a 2018 guardianship that Stish says was vacated so he could enlist.

“If I was prohibited from a firearm I wouldn’t have been in the military for three years where I possessed an N4 and was around weapons of mass destruction all the time,” Stish told Valley News Live.

072726.N.FF.Courthouse.3
Photo: inforum.com

Two charges, two dismissals

Prosecutors initially charged Stish on July 17 with possessing firearms as a prohibited person due to mental health adjudication, the Forum reported. Ten days later, they swapped that count for a National Firearms Act violation: receiving or possessing an unregistered firearm.

The Forum reported that U.S. Attorney Nick Chase confirmed Monday the dismissal resulted from a change in the law after provisions in the One Big Beautiful Bill, signed in July 2025, eliminated taxes on NFA firearms, prompting a Texas lawsuit that struck down the registration mandate.

A separate Cass County case involving a silencer was dismissed in late August on the same Texas ruling, the Forum noted.

Questions about the 2023 shooting

During questioning, officers pressed Stish on why he brought a gun to the fair after the 2023 incident in which a gunman headed toward the event killed one Fargo officer and wounded two others and a civilian, Valley News Live reported.

Federal Complaint Dismissed Against Fargo Man Accused of Carrying Rifle at Street Fair
Photo: northdakota-express.com

“Yes, because of what happened in 2023, which the police officers drilled me,” Stish said, recalling their questions. “I wasn’t here when this happened. I was under training in Fort Jackson.”

Owen Stish, to Valley News Live

Stish said he does not fault the officers for investigating. “If the person they talked to was actually prohibited from firearms or had a serious charge and they just let the person go… it could have ended very badly,” he told Valley News Live. “So they did exactly what they were supposed to with the information that they had.”

What happens next

Stish is petitioning for the return of his firearm and says he wants to move on. Neither the government’s motion nor the court’s order specifies whether the case can be refiled, Valley News Live reported. The federal docket currently shows no pending counts.

North Dakota law permits open carry of an unloaded handgun in plain view without a permit, provided the carrier immediately informs law enforcement if stopped. Street fair organizers say the event has no specific policy banning firearms.