FC Cincinnati’s playoff run continues Sunday at GEODIS Park, where the Orange and Blue open a best-of-three series against Nashville SC at 4 PM.
The matchup pits the Supporters’ Shield winners against a Cincinnati side that scratched into the knockout round with a gritty win in Orlando. Nashville set the MLS points record and won 15 matches at home, becoming just the seventh team in league history to finish a regular season unbeaten on its own turf.
Cincinnati, by contrast, lost both regular-season meetings against the Boys in Gold by a combined 6-0 scoreline and has yet to score a goal against them this season.
“In the playoffs, the only thing that matters is winning,” the preview said, framing the underdog mentality that carried FC Cincinnati through a messy but effective performance against Orlando City. Roman Celentano made outstanding saves in the 24th minute on Marco Pasalic’s header. Evander entered Thursday’s match with zero goals in his previous five playoff matches.
Miles Robinson and Nick Hagglund were both pulled at halftime in Orlando after what the preview described as a “rough night,” though both are available for selection Sunday. Teenage Hadebe remains out with a leg injury, leaving Noonan to choose three guys he thinks can communicate and defend as a unit against Nashville’s defense, which surrendered only 25 goals all season.
“For Nashville, it is pretty simple—play your game,” the preview said. “BJ Callaghan’s men have a formula that worked all season at home. There is no need to change any tactics or rotate the squad at all. Everyone is rested, and all players are available for selection.”
FC Cincinnati initially announced itself as a United Soccer League franchise on August 12, 2015, before securing its MLS spot on May 29, 2018, with play beginning on March 2, 2019. During its USL tenure, the club set several attendance records, including drawing 25,308 for a game against Orlando City B on August 5, 2017.
Cincinnati’s postseason pedigree in the best-of-three format offers a sliver of optimism. The club is 2-1 in the three years of this playoff configuration, with Noonan leading them to series wins over Red Bull New York in 2023 and against Columbus Crew last season. Their only loss came against New York City FC in 2024. But those series didn’t start with a 6-0 aggregate deficit against the opponent.
