Federal Judge Narrows Colorado Semiautomatic Gun Permit Lawsuit, Dismisses Facial Challenge

A federal judge in Denver has gutted the broadest challenge to Colorado’s new permit-to-purchase law for semiautomatic firearms, leaving only a handful of individual claims alive as the case heads toward a jury trial next spring.

U.S. District Court Senior Judge William J. Martínez ruled Wednesday that the Colorado State Shooting Association and its members cannot prove the law is unconstitutional in every application, dismissing their facial challenge under the Second Amendment. The decision, first reported by Colorado Newsline, followed his November 5 order denying a preliminary injunction and effectively endorsed the “shall-issue” framework the legislature built last year.

Senate Bill 25-3 requires anyone buying most semiautomatic guns that accept detachable magazines to obtain a permit from their county sheriff, complete safety training, and pass an exam.

The plaintiffs argued the scheme — wait times for classes, fees, and bureaucratic friction — amounted to a de facto ban. Martínez disagreed, writing that the delays cited in the complaint are “incidental and reflect time necessary to satisfy” the law’s requirements, not evidence of governmental abuse.

“Plaintiffs’ facial challenge under the Second Amendment fails to overcome the presumption of constitutionality afforded to the (permit-to-purchase) shall-issue regime and fails at step one of the Bruen analysis,” Martínez wrote in his November 18 order.

Federal Judge Narrows Colorado Semiautomatic Gun Permit Lawsuit, Dismisses Facial Challenge
Photo: coloradopolitics.com

The Bruen test and the ‘shall-issue’ precedent

The ruling leans heavily on the Supreme Court’s 2022 decision in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen, which established a two-step test: first, whether the regulated conduct falls under the Second Amendment’s text; second, whether the government can show a historical tradition of analogous regulation.

Martínez found Colorado’s law clears the first hurdle because the Supreme Court has explicitly blessed “shall-issue” licensing regimes — systems where authorities must issue a permit if objective criteria are met.

Colorado Politics said that Martínez, a Barack Obama appointee, reiterated that the plaintiffs must do more than allege the regime burdens the Second Amendment; they must plausibly allege it is put toward “abusive ends.” The judge wrote that fees would need to be sufficiently “exorbitant” to effectively deny ordinary citizens their rights, a threshold the current complaint does not meet.

Federal judge upholds Colorado's gun laws

Early data shows demand, not denial

The state offered early implementation numbers to support its case. In August, the first month the permit requirements took effect, sheriffs received over 3,500 applications and 502 people passed the exam necessary to become eligible to purchase covered firearms, according to figures cited in the ruling. The throughput suggests the pipeline is functioning, however slowly, undercutting the argument that the law operates as a constructive prohibition.

Four plaintiffs fight on with ‘as-applied’ claims

The case is not over. Martínez allowed four individual plaintiffs to proceed with “as-applied” challenges — arguments that the law is unconstitutional as it operates on their specific circumstances.

Among them: a disabled veteran and two frequent gun buyers who intend to purchase firearms covered by the statute. Focal News identified the case as Del Toro et al. v. Polis et al. and confirmed a jury trial is set for next spring.

Rapid-fire device ban survives on ‘accessory’ logic

In a separate but decisive blow to the plaintiffs, Martínez dismissed all claims related to the law’s ban on rapid-fire trigger devices. He ruled they are accessories, not “arms” protected by the Second Amendment.

The Colorado Attorney General’s Office had argued that even the plaintiffs described the items as “accessories” in their filings, and that a “firearm accessory” is “not a weapon in itself” and therefore cannot be a “bearable arm.”

Plaintiffs’ attorney Michael D. McCoy countered that anything facilitating armed self-defense qualifies, arguing a rapid-fire device “is added to optimize a firearm’s performance — making it fire faster and more efficiently.”

Martínez rejected that reading as “absurd — a flashlight doubtless facilitates armed self-defense, but it is clearly not an ‘arm.'” He cited a 2018 Tenth Circuit decision holding that a silencer is a firearm accessory, not a bearable arm, as controlling precedent.

Born José Guillermo Martínez Escalante in Mexico City in 1954, William J. Martínez moved to the United States as a child and adopted his current name in 1974.

He grew up in Chicago’s South Shore community and earned degrees from the University of Illinois and the University of Chicago Law School before building a career in employment and civil rights law in Denver. President Barack Obama nominated him to the federal bench in 2010; the Senate confirmed him by a 58–37 vote, and he assumed senior status in February 2023.

Neither the Colorado State Shooting Association nor McCoy immediately responded to requests for comment, Colorado Newsline reported.