Florida AG Announces Arrests at Orlando Halal Butcher Shop Over Animal Abuse

Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier announced Friday afternoon that state and federal officers had arrested multiple people at Ali Meat International, a halal butcher shop on Dean Road in east Orange County, on charges of aggravated animal abuse.

The raid capped a months-long investigation triggered by a complaint filed in September by Animal Outlook, a Washington, D.C.-based animal rights group.

The organization documented 25 alleged violations of Florida’s Humane Slaughter Act and requested $250,000 in fines after receiving video footage showing customers — including a young boy assisted by an adult — slicing the throats of lambs, goats, and cattle, with some animals vocalizing in pain for more than three minutes.

“It was some of the worst cruelty we’d ever seen.”

Ben Williamson

Ben Williamson, Animal Outlook’s executive director, said Friday. He described the footage of a child being helped to cut a lamb’s throat as “horrific.” Florida law requires livestock to be slaughtered by a humane method that is rapid and effective.

Uthmeier’s office released few details Friday, declining to identify those arrested or specify how many face charges. A joint news conference with Agriculture Commissioner Wilton Simpson is scheduled for Monday to outline the case.

The U.S. Department of Agriculture participated in the operation; Secretary Brooke Rollins posted on X that she was “on the ground” in Orlando and that federal investigators had confirmed violations of federal humane slaughter statutes. The USDA immediately revoked Ali Meat’s exemption allowing slaughter without federal inspectors present, effectively halting the facility’s kill operations until federal oversight is restored.

Competing Narratives Converge on a Single Target

The investigation drew attention from ideologically opposed corners. Laura Loomer, a far-right activist previously banned from major social platforms for Islamophobic rhetoric, claimed credit for alerting state officials in September.

“This is what the Islamification of America looks like folks,” Loomer posted at the time, framing the alleged abuses as inherent to Islamic ritual. On Friday, she celebrated the raid and used dehumanizing language toward the suspects. Governor Ron DeSantis amplified Uthmeier’s announcement, writing, “Good. These places should be shut down.”

Animal Outlook, by contrast, approached the case strictly as an animal welfare matter. Williamson emphasized that the group’s complaint focused on statutory violations — failure to stun, prolonged suffering, and lack of trained personnel — regardless of the facility’s religious designation.

The convergence of a progressive advocacy group and a far-right influencer on the same evidence shows how graphic the underlying footage was, but it also complicates the public discourse: the legal charges center on cruelty statutes, not religious practice.

Florida AG Announces Arrests at Orlando Halal Butcher Shop Over Animal Abuse
Photo: wltreport.com

What the Law Requires — And What Comes Next

Florida’s Humane Slaughter Act and the federal Humane Methods of Slaughter Act both mandate that livestock be rendered insensible to pain before slaughter, typically through stunning, with narrow exemptions for ritual slaughter that still require the cut to be swift and the animal to lose consciousness rapidly.

The video described by Williamson suggests neither standard was met. The USDA's revocation of the "custom exempt" status — which had allowed Ali Meat to operate without continuous federal inspection — is a major regulatory escalation; the facility cannot legally slaughter another animal until a federal inspector is on site for every kill.

Uthmeier’s office has not released the charging affidavit, the names of the defendants, or the specific counts beyond “aggravated animal abuse.” The business has been incorporated since 2012 and operates without a public website; calls went unanswered Friday. Monday’s press conference is expected to clarify the number of arrestees, the evidentiary basis for the aggravated charges, and whether the state will pursue permanent closure.