Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier has set his sights on Saint Stephen’s Episcopal School in Bradenton, launching an investigation into the private institution following allegations that students were expelled after their families raised concerns about instructional materials.
The move marks another intervention by the attorney general into the state’s education system, as the office demands answers by November 30 regarding the school’s handling of controversial books and tuition policies.
The conflict centers on whether the private school violated Florida’s deceptive and unfair trade practices law. Uthmeier claims the school misled parents who were told the curriculum was free of LGBTQ-related instructional material. Following internal complaints from multiple families, those students were subsequently expelled, and the school intends to keep the full-year tuition paid by the parents—a cost of $31,900 per seventh-grader.
Schools cannot mislead families about their curriculum, then expel children and keep a full year’s tuition when parents object. My office has demanded that Saint Stephen’s Episcopal School preserve records, stop collections, and make these families whole. Florida parents will… pic.twitter.com/oGTJcDOXvC
So we’re going to take action.”
The attorney general’s office has specifically flagged titles such as The Poet X, Girl, Annie John, and Answers in the Pages. Uthmeier contends that these books contain sexually explicit and suggestive content that contradicts the school’s own handbook, which prohibits pornography and obscene material on campus.
In a letter addressed to Head of School Peter A. Kraft, Uthmeier ordered the institution to preserve all relevant records and cease any effort to collect tuition from these families or withhold their children’s records.

Saint Stephen’s Episcopal School maintains that it has operated in good faith. In a statement, the school expressed confidence in its actions, stating, “We are confident we have acted ethically and in accordance with our educational values, policies, and Florida law. We look forward to providing the AG’s office with the facts and documentation they’ve requested.”
This investigation arrives at a moment of heightened scrutiny for Florida’s educational institutions, and it is not the first time Uthmeier has entered into a Florida schools matter.
Just recently, he took the side of a student’s family in a clash at Sarasota’s Pine View School, an incident that resulted in disciplinary proceedings against history teacher Elizabeth Ballard. The state Education Commissioner, Henry Mack, has found “probable cause” to justify further punishment against Ballard, who has 20 years of classroom experience and is appealing prior suspensions.
NOW: Florida AG James Uthmeier says his office will take action after accusing Saint Stephen’s Episcopal School in Bradenton of misleading parents about sexually explicit classroom material.@AGJamesUthmeier: "If you're going to receive hundreds of millions of dollars in state… pic.twitter.com/RVD4RJRJ1y”
The broader tension between the state and private institutions extends to the Florida Conference of Catholic Bishops, who have clashed with Uthmeier over whether parochial schools must grant religious exemptions for student vaccinations.
The stakes for families remain high. With the November 30 deadline approaching, the case forces a difficult question: how much control should private institutions retain over their curricula when that control conflicts with the expectations of paying parents or state-level legal interpretations? The administration at Saint Stephen’s faces an official inquiry, while the legal battle over transparency, tuition, and classroom content continues in the Florida capital.