Florida to Execute Thomas Overton Thursday, Breaking Annual Record Amid Innocence Claims

Florida is set to execute Thomas Overton on Thursday evening, a move that would make him the 20th person put to death by the state this year and break the annual record of 19 executions set last year, Floridians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty reported.

The execution is scheduled for 6 p.m. at Florida State Prison, barring a last-minute intervention by the U.S. Supreme Court. Grace Hanna, executive director of FADP, said she will be outside the prison alongside Joaquín José Martínez, who was exonerated from Florida’s death row, and she described Overton’s case as among the most outrageous she has encountered.

“It’s hard to read those details and understand how Florida can be sure enough of his guilt to take his life.”

Hanna wrote in a message to supporters, pointing to court filings that allege a veterinarian with only two weeks of serology training took the victims’ bedsheets home, cut pieces from them, and stored evidence in a personal refrigerator. Police also handed evidence to a psychic who handled it without gloves, according to FADP.

Overton was convicted of the 1991 murders of Susan and Michael MacIvor. The petition to Governor Ron DeSantis and the Florida Board of Executive Clemency notes that DNA evidence used to convict Overton may have been planted, citing the presence of a chemical associated with spermicidal condoms on a mattress pad beneath a fitted sheet.

Hairs found on the tape used to bind the victims have yet to undergo modern DNA testing.

Overton petition graphic
Photo: actionnetwork.org

Overton is a veteran and a survivor of the Dozier School for Boys, the state-run reform school where nearly 100 children died. Hanna noted that DeSantis signed legislation compensating Dozier survivors, acknowledging the state’s responsibility for the harm inflicted there. “That acknowledgment must extend to how Florida treats those survivors today, including a man facing execution whose innocence claim remains unresolved,” the ActionNetwork.org petition states.

The state has at least two more executions scheduled before the end of 2026: Ricardo Gonzales on December 1 and Willie Crain on December 10. FADP is urging residents to attend county legislative delegation meetings over the coming months to press lawmakers for a halt to executions and a review of the system. A virtual vigil for Overton is scheduled to begin at 5 p.m. ET on Thursday.