“It’s disingenuous to say he led soldiers into combat or did direct action activities in combat zones,” said Lt. Col. Jamie Gottschling, Moore’s direct supervisor in Afghanistan, in an interview with WBFF.
The allegation cuts to the core of the public biography Gov. Wes Moore has cultivated for nearly two decades. Gottschling, a retired Army officer, told the Baltimore Fox affiliate he believes Moore’s repeated claims of leading troops in firefights amount to stolen valor. The dispute resurfaced this week as Moore, a Democrat widely mentioned as a potential 2028 presidential contender, campaigns for a second term.
Moore served in the U.S. Army Reserve from 1996 to 2014, reaching the rank of captain. From August 2005 to March 2006, he deployed to Afghanistan as an information operations officer attached to the 82nd Airborne Division’s 1st Brigade, Military.com reported. Gottschling describes that role as a staff position analyzing reports and occasionally going “outside the wire” to work with Afghan officials on civilian assistance — not leading paratroopers in direct combat.
“He’s not a soldier. He was in the Army as a reservist in a staff position in Iraq. But I wouldn’t call him a soldier,” Gottschling added.

Bronze Star listed before formal award
The combat narrative is not the only element of Moore’s record under scrutiny. In 2006, Moore listed a Bronze Star on a White House Fellowship application despite not having received the medal.
He later called it an “honest mistake,” saying his commanding officer at the time, Lt. Gen. Michael Fenzel, had told him the paperwork was approved. Following a 2024 New York Times report on the omission, Fenzel resubmitted the recommendation and Moore was formally awarded the medal late last year.
Gottschling told WBFF he was not consulted during that belated approval process. “I wasn’t consulted in that matter,” he said.
Questions also surround a passage in Moore’s 2006 book, The Work: Searching for a Life That Matters. Moore wrote of seeing Sgt. Toby Meister “inside that casket” at his grandfather’s funeral.
But Meister was still alive at the time of that funeral; he was killed by a roadside bomb in Afghanistan 11 days later. Meister’s widow told Spotlight on Maryland, “I don’t know who Moore is. I don’t recall my late husband ever talking about him.”
Moore calls criticism partisan retaliation
Moore pushed back sharply this week, framing Gottschling’s criticism as partisan retaliation. “He’s come home, and he’s now become a MAGA supporter and a MAGA donor, and I’m just really thankful for the service I did,” Moore said at a press conference.

Gottschling rejects the political motive. He told WBFF he spoke with Moore only once since Afghanistan — when Moore called seeking campaign support. “I flat out said no. I can’t support you in the campaign because we can’t be more different in our beliefs,” Gottschling said.
“I’m trying to pursue the truth here and get the record straight. Even if he was a Republican I’d do the same thing.”
On Wednesday, Moore cited a statement from retired Marine 1st Lt. Anthony Del Signore as proof his combat claims had been “debunked.” Del Signore confirmed he and Moore were part of a convoy that took fire from an Afghan mountainside and had to dismount.
But Del Signore’s account does not corroborate Moore’s central claim — that he led soldiers in an offensive firefight, responding with “overwhelming force,” The Washington Free Beacon reported. Asked directly if he could confirm Moore led troops in combat, Del Signore replied, “You can use the statement I’ve already provided.” When pressed that his statement did not support that claim, he answered, “No problem.”
Gottschling told the Free Beacon the convoy incident Del Signore described sounds like “harassing fire” — “potshots at convoys” — not the sustained engagement Moore describes. He noted the Combat Action Badge Moore received was for a December 2005 indirect-fire incident on base in which no one was injured, not for the convoy episode.
National Republicans escalate
The controversy has drawn fire from prominent Republicans. Rep. Derrick Van Orden, R-Wis., a former Navy SEAL, called Moore’s conduct “despicable,” “shameful,” and “criminal.”
“What your governor has done is despicable. It’s shameful, and I believe it’s criminal,” Van Orden told WBFF. “I can’t describe in strong enough terms how disgraceful this person is. It’s absolutely shameful.”
Van Orden demanded Moore apologize to Gold Star families and step down. “Where did he lead ’em to? The chow hall?” he asked.
Moore’s office did not respond to requests for comment from Military.com by publication time. The governor told journalist Chuck Todd earlier this month he is “still sorting it out” regarding a potential 2028 presidential run.