Former Mitchell baseball player Peyton Mandel has appealed a judge’s dismissal of his defamation lawsuit to the South Dakota Supreme Court, court filings show.
The appeal, filed November 2 and recorded by the court November 18, challenges Circuit David Knoff’s October order granting summary judgment to the American Legion, Forum Communications and Nexstar Media Group, South Dakota News Watch reported. Mandel argues that a letter from American Legion adjutant C.P. Van Delist falsely branded him a rapist after he pleaded guilty only to accessory to a felony in a 2023 hazing case.
Van Delist’s November 2024 letter to the Mitchell Baseball Association said that all six players involved “are guilty of accessory to a felony, acknowledging by affirmation of their guilty pleas, that the felonies they were charged with, rape and aiding and abetting, did take place.” The letter prompted the American Legion to bar Mitchell Baseball from participation immediately.
In his August ruling, Judge Knoff said that Mandel’s case against Forum Communications and Mitchell Republic editor Luke Hagen rested on a vague admission and the contention that he did not technically admit in court to being an accessory to rape or to aiding and abetting rape, and he dismissed those claims. He extended that reasoning to all defendants in October, effectively closing the case at the circuit level.
The hazing incident occurred at a Rapid City hotel in 2023, where another player said he was held down and subjected to forcible digital anal penetration. As part of a plea deal, Mandel pleaded guilty in 2024 to one count of accessory to a felony. He maintains he never admitted to rape or aiding and abetting rape, the specific distinction at the heart of his defamation claim.
The Supreme Court docket lists the case as “not ready for hearing” while both sides prepare briefs. The court decides appeals either through 15-minute oral arguments per side or by reviewing the lower court record and written submissions alone. Justices Scott P. Myren, Mark E. Salter, Chief Justice Steven R. Jensen, Patricia J. Devaney and Robert Gusinsky comprise the panel that would hear the matter.
Mandel and his attorney, Tucker Volesky, have two other civil lawsuits pending. In August they sued Pennington County State’s Attorney Lara Roetzel, Nexstar and NewsNation host Chris Cuomo, alleging malicious prosecution and a “prejudicial publicity campaign” against the six players.
A September suit targets Nexstar and five KELOLAND reporters, claiming coverage after the 2024 criminal proceedings portrayed Mandel “not merely as a person charged in a criminal case or who pleaded guilty to accessory to a crime without admitting any sexual conduct” but as a “direct perpetrator of rape against a minor.”
South Dakota Supreme Court traces its roots to the Dakota Territory’s high court, established in Yankton in 1861 as the nation’s first territorial supreme court; President Abraham Lincoln appointed its three original justices. The court heard no cases until December 3, 1867, and grew to eight members before statehood split the territory in 1889.
South Dakota’s first state justices were elected and sworn on October 15, 1889, taking the oath on the Hughes County courthouse veranda because no capitol existed. The court did not occupy its own chambers until 1905.
Attorneys involved in the appeal did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
Worth a look
- Richmond Opens First Rail-to-Trail Path, Linking Southside Neighborhoods With $9M ARPA Project
- Arkansas Unemployment Rate Falls to 3.8% as Payrolls Hit Record High
- Italy’s Supreme Court Upholds Life Sentence for Ex-Doctor Who Killed Wife, Mother-in-Law with Drug Cocktail (archyde.com)
- Trump administration moves to dismiss lawsuit over Alaska Senate race (newsarchyuk.com)