Former RI Priest James Silva, 86, Avoids Prison With Probation in Child Molestation Plea

Former Rhode Island priest James M. Silva, 86, pleaded no contest Thursday to molesting a boy in the late 1980s and was sentenced to 10 years of probation, avoiding prison for the second time in three decades.

Superior Court Judge Richard Raspallo accepted the plea to one count each of first- and second-degree child molestation and dismissed nine other charges, The Boston Globe reported.

“I have forgiven you but I will never forget,” the victim, Ronald McKeon, told Silva in court. “You knew I was damaged because of my parents’ divorce. I must have looked like an easy target to you. This day was a long time coming for you and I’m glad it’s here.”

McKeon, now 49, described complex PTSD, nightmares, and a decades-long battle with addiction that he traced to the abuse. He said he is now sober, has a relationship with his sons, and plans to begin PTSD treatment.

Former RI Priest James Silva, 86, Avoids Prison With Probation in Child Molestation Plea
Photo: coastalabc.com

“What you did to me has made my life very hard to live,” McKeon said. “I have been in legal troubles because of not caring about myself due to the abuse I suffered at your hand.”

He added, “My relationship with God was not there. McKeon said he now has a strong relationship with God and a partner who loved him when he could not love himself. “May God forgive you and may I keep praying for you.”

The case is one of roughly 200 lawsuits filed since Rhode Island opened a two-year revival window on July 1 for expired child sexual abuse claims against institutions, the Providence Journal reported. McKeon’s suit names the Diocese of Providence alongside Silva. Two other men have filed similar suits. McKeon gave the attorney general’s office permission to make his statement public. It remains unclear whether prosecutors or victims will pursue further legal action.

Former RI priest pleads no contest to child molestation, avoids jail time — WPRI

A pattern known for decades

Silva joined the ministry in 1967. By the 1970s and 1980s, then-Bishop Louis Gelineau was repeatedly warned about him yet transferred him across roughly 12 parishes in 15 years, according to court records cited by The Boston Globe.

After a Navy chaplain reported one case in 1981, Gelineau allegedly responded, “Oh, no. Not again!” Gelineau himself has been accused of raping a boy in Barrington in the 1980s, according to a lawsuit filed this fall.

Silva was interim director of the diocese’s Office of Ministerial Formation when he met McKeon’s mother, who was taking evening classes there between 1986 and June 13, 1990. After her 1987 divorce, Silva offered to watch her son, then 12.

Prosecutor Jonathan Burke told the court Silva took the boy on outings, including fast food, fondled him while driving, and performed oral sex on him at Silva’s East Providence home at 7 South Carpenter Street, the Providence Journal reported.

Burke said Silva had the boy sit on his lap “under the pretext of showing the victim how to drive his car” and told him he was “gonna show [him] some things adults do.”

Silva was sent to a treatment center in New Mexico but abused another boy after returning to Rhode Island in 1991, court records show. He was removed from ministry in March 1993 and pleaded guilty to second-degree sexual assault in 1995, receiving a seven-year suspended sentence and probation — no jail time then, either.

The Diocese of Providence, erected by Pope Pius IX on February 16, 1872, originally encompassed all of Rhode Island plus parts of Massachusetts including Cape Cod, Martha’s Vineyard, Nantucket, and the Fall River area. Its first bishop, Thomas Hendricken, oversaw a territory of 125,000 parishioners, 43 churches, nine parish schools, and one orphanage.

The institutional reckoning

Silva has been on the diocese’s public list of credibly accused clergy for years. The latest plea adds a criminal bookend to a civil wave that has surged since the legislature’s lookback window opened. McKeon gave the attorney general’s office permission to make his statement public. It remains unclear whether prosecutors or victims will pursue further legal action.