Former Tennessee PTO President Indicted for Misappropriating Over $57,000 in School Funds

A former Tennessee elementary school PTO president has been indicted after investigators determined she misappropriated more than $57,000 in organization funds.

Samantha Zimmerman, who led the parent-teacher organization at Bel-Aire Elementary School in Tullahoma from August 2023 until her resignation on January 29, 2026, faces one count of theft over $10,000, two counts of forgery and two counts of tampering with governmental records. A Coffee County grand jury returned the indictment in November 2026.

The charges stem from an investigation by the Tennessee Comptroller’s Office, which found Zimmerman misappropriated at least $57,522.62. Investigators identified $31,820.49 in cash withdrawals from the PTO’s bank account that Zimmerman acknowledged were unrelated to PTO operations and used for personal expenses.

Another $21,215.86 in personal purchases was made with a PTO debit card, covering entertainment, household items, food, clothing, vehicle maintenance and storage unit rentals. Five of the six storage units rented with PTO funds were for Zimmerman’s personal use, the Comptroller’s Office said.

Investigators also determined Zimmerman misappropriated at least $4,486.27 collected through fundraisers and Venmo transactions. The office identified $20,000 in repayments made by Zimmerman, leaving $37,522.62 unrecovered.

Beyond the confirmed theft, the investigation uncovered significant financial mismanagement. In August 2025, Zimmerman reported the PTO held approximately $34,938 in its bank account; bank records showed the account contained less than $1,900 at that time. Investigators also flagged at least $77,307.96 in questionable disbursements that could not be verified because supporting records were missing. That figure was identified separately from the confirmed misappropriation and was not established as additional stolen funds.

“School support organizations must maintain accurate financial records and make sure financial responsibilities are properly divided among officers.”

Tennessee Comptroller Jason Mumpower said.

“Allowing one person to control deposits, spending, and bank reconciliations without adequate oversight creates an unnecessary opportunity for fraud to occur without prompt detection.”

Bel-Aire Elementary School is part of the Tullahoma City School District in Coffee County. The district reported the financial discrepancies that prompted the investigation.