Fort Orange Brewing will close December 19 after nine years in Albany’s warehouse district, with regular hours continuing Wednesday through Friday 5 to 9 p.m. and Saturday 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. until then.
Fort Orange Brewing will close December 19 after nine years in Albany’s warehouse district, WNYT.com NewsChannel 13 NewsChannel 13 reported Monday.
The three co-owners — Jim Eaton, Craig Johnson and John Westcott — announced the decision on social media, calling it the right choice for their families. The taproom at 450 North Pearl Street will remain open through that Saturday with a final celebration planned for the last night, according to the Facebook post cited by WNYT.com NewsChannel 13.
“This was not an easy decision, but it is the right one for our families,” the owners wrote. “When we first opened our doors, we never could have imagined the amazing people, friendships and memories that would become such a big part of this journey.”

Eaton told the Times Union on Tuesday that rising costs and declining traffic drove the decision. “Costs for everything are through the roof,” he said, “and unless we were having an event, we were seeing a lot less foot traffic.” Orders from local beverage centers had also fallen, signaling less at-home consumption, he told the paper.
“People just don’t have as much money for fun or going out,” he said. Over the near-decade they spent building and running the business, “We’ve all had day jobs, (and) we all have families,” Eaton said. “There’s only so much a human being can do in terms of keeping the candle burning at both ends.”
A garage dream that anchored a neighborhood
The brewery opened October 25, 2017, in a vacant garage the friends from Castleton had taken over, the Times Union reported. Eaton, Johnson and Westcott came from careers in banking, higher education and engineering.
They launched with a seven-barrel system and a 2,100-square-foot tasting room, adding fermenters over the years to reach six. Eaton estimated they brewed 100 to 125 different beers, with a peanut butter stout becoming so popular a customer from Vermont bought 15 cases to last through the pandemic. They started as home brewers.
Despite ingredient, equipment and rent increases, the partners raised the price of a pint only once — by $1 to $8 — over nine years, Eaton told the Times Union.
The taproom became known for trivia, bingo, cornhole tournaments and seasonal events like the “Island of Misfit Toys Variety Show” scheduled for November 27 and a candle-making workshop December 1. The eighth annual Thanksgiving Eve Cornhole Tourney is also planned. Lacking a kitchen, the brewery hosted food trucks and welcomed outside food, the Times Union noted.

New York brewery count drops from 535 to 500
The closure mirrors a broader contraction. Spectrum Local News reported in April that New York’s craft brewery count had fallen to about 500 from a New York State Brewers Association peak of roughly 535 in 2024, Hoodline reported. Those breweries still represent an estimated $4.8 billion in economic impact and 22,000 jobs, the association told Spectrum.
“Are breweries closing? Yes. Will they continue to close? Yes, for a variety of reasons,” Leone told Spectrum. “But we’re seeing at the same time in New York that breweries are continuing to open.” Closures eased to 481 from 591 the year before. The association said hospitality-driven brewpubs and taprooms remained comparatively resilient.
The final celebration December 19 will feature live music, food and beer, the owners said. Regular hours continue Wednesday through Friday 5 to 9 p.m. and Saturday 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. until then.