Forty thousand business filings sit frozen in a state system that went live on July 6

Forty thousand business filings sit frozen in a state system that went live on July 6, and the vendor hired to build it had never worked with the platform before.

That gap between the launch date and the reality inside the Hawaii Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs dominated a two-hour legislative briefing on Nov. 10, where lawmakers pressed DCCA Director Nadine Ando and state Chief Information Officer Christine Sakuda on a modernization project that began in 2022.

The department processes hundreds of thousands of transactions a year for more than 200,000 active entities; for months, many of them have been unable to file required registration documents, triggering missed deadlines and operational interruptions across the islands.

“We recognize the seriousness of the challenges, and the frustrations it has caused the business community, and are working diligently, as the highest priority in our department, to find a solution and get through the backlog,” Ando told the House Committee on Consumer Protection and Commerce.

Hawaii, Salesforce Address Business Registry Modernization
Photo: europesays.com

“Why did we hire a company with no Salesforce experience to build a Salesforce platform, and rely on them to just kind of sub out all the work,”

Rep. Scot Matayoshi, CPC chair

The state contracted with Pacxa, a Hawaii-based government services technology provider, as prime contractor. Melissa Ah Ho-Mauga, DCCA information systems manager, confirmed to the committee that Pacxa lacked experience with the Salesforce platform — a revelation that drew a sharp response from Rep. Scot Matayoshi, who chairs the oversight committee.

Pacxa President Kelly Ueoka said in an emailed statement that the firm was selected to lead modernization and coordinate delivery among partners, delivering the new system on July 6 and completing more than 20,000 filings to date.

Ueoka said the rollout was complicated by roughly 25,000 previously backlogged filings on top of ongoing new submissions, and that Salesforce and DCCA are now collaborating on remediation strategies while Pacxa assigns up to 20 employees to assist with customer calls.

The vendor gap and the oversight gap

Salesforce was not the primary vendor on the project, officials said. The platform company has since deployed its professional services team to work on the backlog and a new application “at no cost to the state,” Ando said, targeting full operational status by mid-January. That two-track effort runs while DCCA staff sift through an inbox holding roughly 7,000 emails from businesses and nonprofits demanding answers.

Oversight for the project relied on an independent verification and validation provider, Sakuda told the committee. She described the IVV as a “litmus test on the health of the project” and said she wants to strengthen governance around that process.

Matayoshi called the state’s operational detachment insufficient, noting an ETS representative attended project meetings. “Maybe what we could do a better job of is sharing lessons learned across the projects, and challenging ourselves to really adhere to those lessons learned, and also, where we need support, to ask,” Sakuda said.

“It sounds like you guys jumped out of a plane without a parachute. It sounds like you went live with no way to backtrack if anything went wrong,”

Rep. Scot Matayoshi, CPC chair

Matayoshi argued the state should avoid hiring vendors lacking expertise in the deployed software and require a clear rollback plan for future modernizations.

“For future modernization projects, I hope — we can stress test as much as we want — but I hope other departments … will build a back door, or build an escape hatch or something, that if things go wrong, you have that built-in thing to revert back to while you’re fixing it,” he said.

ETS and DCCA did not immediately respond to emailed questions seeking comment. DCCA has acknowledged “processing delays affecting Hawaii businesses” in a news release updated Monday.