Georgetown Repeals Controversial Cottage Housing Law Amid Mixed Reactions

Georgetown has officially repealed a divisive zoning ordinance that once cleared the path for cottage-style housing developments.

The Town Council voted 3 to 1 on Nov. 9 to strike down the law, a decision that arrives even as the town remains entangled in an ongoing lawsuit regarding the future of cottage housing within its borders.

The repeal marks a reversal for a town that stood as one of the only municipalities in the state of Delaware to permit cottage communities. While the vote effectively closes the door on future projects of this nature, it does not reach back to dismantle existing approvals.

A cottage community project led by the nonprofit Little Living, specifically designed for low-income families and working individuals, remains protected because the Council had already granted it the green light.

During public comment sessions leading up to the vote, opposition was vocal and consistent. Some neighbors expressed fears that the housing model—despite being intended for the working class—would eventually invite homelessness into the town.

“If this turns into a trailer park situation, we’re done,” resident Janice Jones said during the meeting. “To protect our property values, to protect our neighborhoods, to protect our kids, we cannot give things away and expect gold in return.”

Springboard Delaware and Mayor Townsend Oppose the Ordinance

The repeal effort gained momentum alongside a legal challenge from Springboard Delaware, a nonprofit currently developing its own cottage community in the area. The organization also manages the town’s Navigation Shelter, or Pallet Village, which provides transitional housing for those experiencing homelessness.

Mayor Angela Townsend, who was not in office when the original ordinance passed nearly a year ago, made no secret of her opposition to the policy from the start.

“I was on the outside when this was passed. I was one of the ones standing at the podium saying we don’t need it,” Townsend told the Council this week. “But we weren’t listened to, and I think that’s what hurt most of all.”

Townsend was joined in the majority vote by Councilmembers Michael Briggs and Penuel Barrett. For Barrett, the decision was about correcting what he described as a failed experiment, calling the town a “guinea pig of disaster” regarding the cottage housing model. Conversely, Councilmember Tony Neal provided the sole dissenting vote, arguing that cottage communities could benefit the town.

The Economic Reality of the Housing Gap

Data from Housing Delaware, formerly known as the Delaware State Housing Authority, underscores the scale of the challenge. A 2023 report from the agency identified a shortfall of almost 20,000 affordable homes across the state for renters earning less than half the area median income.

A two-person household earning 50% of the area median income in 2023 brought home an annual salary of about $30,000. For these residents, the repeal of the cottage housing law removes one of the options for lower-cost living.

“The people making our sandwiches, processing chicken, stocking shelves and cleaning buildings can work hard every day and still struggle to find housing. Dismissing the gap between wages and housing cost does not make it go away. Cottage housing gives people another option to close that gap,” said Georgetown resident Jon Peterson.

Housing Delaware Director Matthew Heckles submitted a letter to the Council ahead of the vote, explicitly urging them to reconsider the repeal. Heckles argued that maintaining the cottage housing option was vital for meeting the region’s diverse housing needs and supporting broader efforts to stabilize the market.

As the town moves forward, the legal proceedings involving Springboard Delaware continue to loom over the municipal agenda. Councilmember Christina Diaz-Malone, who is married to Springboard Delaware’s Director Judson Malone, was absent from the vote.

Georgetown Town Council votes to repeal cottage housing ordinance — CoastTV