Groups Urge Veto of Bill Prohibiting OPTO at the MTA – Reinvent Albany

Governor Kathy Hochul faces a veto decision on legislation that would lock conductors onto New York City subway trains for decades, a move a coalition of civic and business groups says would waste hundreds of millions of dollars and strand the system in the past.

The bill, A10706/S9586, passed the Legislature in June and landed on Hochul’s desk this month. It would forbid the Metropolitan Transportation Authority from expanding one-person train operation — known as OPTO — beyond the lines where it already exists, effectively requiring a conductor on every train that does not currently run with a single operator.

In a letter sent Thursday, Reinvent Albany and nine other organizations urged the governor to reject the measure, arguing it micromanages staffing decisions that should belong to management and labor negotiations.

“This bill does the opposite by raising MTA operating costs and constraining its ability to modernize its operations,” the groups wrote. “We supported your veto of similar legislation last year, and we recommend you veto this bill that would impede the MTA’s ability to provide more efficient, reliable, and modern subway service.”

The signatories read like a who’s who of New York transit policy: the Citizens Budget Commission, the Effective Transit Alliance, the NYU Marron Institute’s Transit Costs Project, the Partnership for New York City, the Regional Plan Association, and Reinvent Albany itself. Their argument rests on three pillars — cost, technology, and global precedent.

“OPTO can provide better service at a lower cost,” the letter says. “CBC estimates that using OPTO systemwide could save more than $425 million annually, which could be reinvested to close the MTA’s structural operating budget gap or improve service for riders.”

That $425 million figure looms large as the MTA stares down a structural deficit that has threatened service cuts and fare hikes. The Citizens Budget Commission, a nonpartisan fiscal watchdog, has argued for years that the conductor role — largely reduced to opening and closing doors on modern lines — is an expensive relic.

The MTA has installed communications-based train control, or CBTC, on the 7 and L lines, allowing trains to drive themselves with an operator aboard. Yet both lines still carry a conductor in a separate cab.

The current capital plan commits more than $12 billion to new rolling stock and modernized signals designed for one-person operation. The legislation would require conductors on those new trains in perpetuity, the groups warn, turning a capital investment in automation into an operating mandate for staffing the groups call unnecessary.

New York is an outlier. The NYU Marron Institute’s Transit Costs Project examined 400 rail lines worldwide and found that fewer than 6 percent use two or more operators. The vast majority — 94 percent — operate with one or zero. Paris began running driverless trains in 2013. London moved to OPTO in 2000.

Stockholm did it in 1975. In the United States, SEPTA in Philadelphia switched in 1984, Chicago in 1998, and Boston in 2012. Newer systems in Washington, San Francisco, and Atlanta opened with one-person operation. Only New York City Transit and the PATH system still staff every train with both an operator and a conductor.

The MTA has actually used OPTO for decades — on shuttles and during off-peak hours since 1996 — without a safety incident attributed to the staffing model. The groups argue that operational strategy should be left to management, accountable through performance metrics and collective bargaining, not frozen by Albany statute.

Labor unions, chiefly the Transport Workers Union Local 100, view the conductor as a critical safety layer — a second set of eyes on the platform, a first responder during emergencies, and a point of human contact for riders.

They argue that the Legislature is right to set a floor on staffing, especially after years of service cuts and deferred maintenance. The union has pointed to incidents where conductors assisted during medical emergencies or helped evacuate trains during fires.

Hochul vetoed a nearly identical bill in December 2023, siding with the MTA’s need for flexibility. She wrote then that the legislation “would prevent the MTA from implementing operational efficiencies that are enabled by new technology.” The current bill passed with veto-proof majorities in both chambers, setting up a potential override fight if she rejects it again.

The governor’s office said Thursday it is reviewing the legislation. A decision is expected before the year-end deadline.