Hawaiʻi Elections Commission Loses Quorum After Democratic Commissioners Challenge Chair, Leave Meeting

The Hawaiʻi Elections Commission lost its quorum and adjourned without conducting business Thursday after three Democratic-appointed commissioners challenged the authority of the temporary chair and left the Zoom meeting, Honolulu Civil Beat reported.

  • Commissioner Jeffrey Osterkamp challenged Tamara McKay’s authority as chair pro tem and was removed from the Zoom meeting.
  • Commissioner Barbara Dalton also left, leaving four Republican-appointed commissioners without a quorum.
  • The panel plans to advertise for a permanent chair and reconvene in January.
  • The Campaign Spending Commission fined six candidates for reporting violations on Wednesday.

Quorum collapses after challenge to chair

The commission had appeared back on track this month after a five-month hiatus, following Hawaiʻi Supreme Court intervention that allowed a public meeting and the election of McKay as temporary chair. Within minutes of Thursday’s meeting, Osterkamp raised a point of order challenging McKay’s authority and arguing the commission was dominated by election deniers. McKay ruled him out of order because the point was not on the agenda and had him cut from the Zoom feed.

“It probably will be stricken from the record, as we now have an election denier as the invalidly elected Chair Pro Tem,” Osterkamp wrote in an email to The Sunshine Blog.

Dalton, also appointed by Democrats, then signed off with “A hui ho.” Two other Democratic appointees, John Sabas and Liana Horovitz, did not attend. The four remaining commissioners — all appointed by Republicans — lacked a quorum under the state Sunshine Law and could not deliberate or make decisions.

The meeting continued for more than two and a half hours with testimony, including from commissioners themselves. Deputy Attorney General James Paige determined the panel could handle administrative business, and members agreed to advertise for a permanent chair and reconvene in January.

Judith Mills Wong, president of the League of Women Voters of Hawaiʻi, told the commission the chair should be nonpartisan and free of conflicts.

“The role of the commission is not to represent the party or a position, but to fairly evaluate and advise on matters concerning the electoral process, and we would ask that there be no conflict of interest, not candidates, not people who have run for office, not people who are planning to run for or in the process of running for office, or their staff, and no one who is in conflict with the state who is suing the state for the electoral process,” she said.

Wong’s criteria would appear to exclude McKay, a past chair of the Hawaiʻi Republican Party, and Commissioner Cushnie, both of whom have sued the state over the electoral process and applied for the chair position in June without securing enough support.

Campaign Spending Commission issues fines

At its Wednesday meeting, the Hawaiʻi Campaign Spending Commission fined six candidates for reporting violations.

Unsuccessful Honolulu City Council candidate Tara Malia Gregory was fined $1,200 for a late filing; she said she had filed “in good faith” but was confused about deadlines. Commissioner Barbara Polk rejected the excuse, saying transparency in campaign spending is essential.

Honolulu City Councilwoman Val Okimoto was fined $781.25 and will pay.

Rep. Darius Kila was fined $300 for a late filing he paid the same day; both were reelected.

Unsuccessful state Senate candidate Christy MacPherson was fined $1,500 for failing to report expenditures. Campaign treasurer Garrett Iha said the expenses were submitted through the online system but did not register for an unexplained reason. Unsuccessful state House candidate Tam Hunt was fined $800 for several reporting errors.

Yamane request denied

The Campaign Spending Commission rejected a request on behalf of former state Rep. Ryan Yamane, who sought an advisory opinion on using about $33,000 in campaign funds for legal fees. Yamane, who served from 2004 to 2023 and later directed the Department of Human Services, was indicted in July on bribery and conspiracy charges.

“I respectfully request a formal advisory opinion interpreting the relevant provisions of Hawaii campaign-finance law and Commission rules as applied to the facts described above,” Isaac Choy, a former state representative, said. The commission said campaign funds cannot be used for legal proceedings unless related to an elections proceeding or administrative agency action.

New chief data officer for Honolulu

Jared Kuroiwa was appointed chief data officer for the City and County of Honolulu by Mayor Rick Blangiardi last week. Kuroiwa will head the Office of the Managing Director to strengthen the city’s use of data, technology, and artificial intelligence. In 2012 he developed a searchable database of Hawaiʻi campaign finance information and co-founded Hawaiʻi Open Data.

Green appears in Disagree Better video

Gov. Josh Green traveled last week to Santa Fe, New Mexico, and Park City, Utah, for meetings of the Western Governors’ Association and the National Governors’ Association. He appears in a new video from Disagree Better, a nonpartisan nonprofit “focused on helping Americans navigate political differences more constructively,” alongside outgoing Nevada Gov. Joe Lombardo, a Republican.

Republican state Rep. Lauren Matsumoto and Democratic state Sen. Troy Hashimoto of Hawaiʻi are also teaming up for an upcoming Disagree Better video, part of a national effort to model respectful disagreement and cooperation.