Herbstreit Calls Oklahoma ‘Trash All Year,’ Questions Four-Loss SEC Teams in CFP Rankings

ESPN analyst Kirk Herbstreit called Oklahoma “trash all year” and questioned the logic behind four SEC teams with 6-4 records holding spots in the bottom of the latest College Football Playoff rankings during an appearance Thursday on The Pat McAfee Show.

The rankings released Tuesday placed South Carolina at No. 21, Oklahoma at No. 22, Florida at No. 24 and Mississippi at No. 25 — all with four losses. “What happened at the bottom doesn’t make a lot of sense to me, with South Carolina losing at Arkansas,” Herbstreit said on the show. “Oklahoma’s been trash all year. Florida’s not a very good team. They’re very erratic and inconsistent.”

South Carolina was drubbed 34-6 on the road by an Arkansas team that entered the game 3-6 and had lost four of its previous five, yet the Gamecocks fell only four spots. Oklahoma entered the top 25 at No. 22 after a 24-17 win over Ole Miss, placing the Sooners one spot behind a South Carolina team that beat them 42-25 in Norman and ahead of 7-3 Louisville.

“I don’t like that bottom line,” Herbstreit said. “I’m not a big fan of a lot of those teams down there from the SEC. I heard Heather (Dinich) and others who have talked about this new thing that they’re talking about, strength of conference or something like that. It’s a new variable, a new metric that they’re looking at. But I was very surprised on that part.”

Herbstreit Calls Oklahoma 'Trash All Year,' Questions Four-Loss SEC Teams in CFP Rankings
Photo: sports.yahoo.com

The SEC bias debate

The committee’s decision to rank four-loss SEC teams over multiple ACC teams with 7-3 records — along with Group of Five programs like Liberty, New Mexico, UTSA and Memphis sporting only one or two losses — has fueled accusations of conference bias. The SEC is the only conference with four-loss teams ranked in the top 25.

Oklahoma’s inclusion drew Herbstreit’s harshest criticism. The Sooners opened the season No. 10 in the AP poll behind quarterback John Mateer and a 10-3 finish a year ago, but the offense collapsed early: a 17-10 loss at Michigan, a 14-6 grind against New Mexico and a 41-13 blowout at Georgia.

They stunned then-No. 1 Texas 27-24 in Dallas, then lost 21-13 at home to Kentucky as Mateer threw three interceptions. A 42-25 home loss to South Carolina dropped Oklahoma to 4-4, prompting coach Brent Venables to fire offensive coordinator Ben Arbuckle and hand play-calling duties to tight ends coach Jason Witten. The Sooners ranked 111th nationally in total offense at the time.

Herbstreit Calls Oklahoma 'Trash All Year,' Questions Four-Loss SEC Teams in CFP Rankings
Photo: sports.yahoo.com

The switch steadied Oklahoma. Wins over Florida (23-7) and Ole Miss (24-17) followed, but the Sooners still sit 4-3 in SEC play with the No. 106 scoring offense in FBS. Venables received a six-year, $63 million extension in August with a $51.67 million buyout, making a midseason firing unlikely despite two in-season offensive coordinator dismissals in two years.

Where the committee got it right

Herbstreit praised the committee for moving Arizona up four spots to No. 19 after a 40-39 loss to No. 2 Utah. The Wildcats fell to 7-3 with all three losses coming to top-12 teams, two decided by one score. “People think we push the SEC, but I push teams,” Herbstreit said.

“If that’s the No. 2 team in the country, and I think they are, Arizona had them on the ropes until the final gun. … Tip of the cap to the committee for doing that, as they sit at 7-3 in the Big 12. How many people would have thought a Big 12 team at 7-3 would be in the top 20 off of a loss late in the year? That’s something they did right.”

Oklahoma hosts Texas A&M Saturday at 3:45 p.m. ET on ESPN2 and closes the regular season at Missouri on Nov. 28.