Historic Columbus 4S Club Reopens Dec. 1 as Upscale Restaurant and Cocktail Bar After Three-Year Renovation

Columbus’s historic 4S Club reopens Dec. 1 as a restaurant and cocktail bar after a three-year, top-to-bottom renovation that preserves the building’s three-sided bar and theater roots while adding a modern kitchen, solar panels and a membership model designed to feel inclusive rather than exclusive.

The private club at 281 E. Whittier St. closed in December 2023 when childhood friends Michael Kelley, John Duffy and Bobby Whitman bought the property the day before purchase offers were due. They wanted to keep the place from becoming “something entirely different,” and spent nearly three years rebuilding the interior around the original bar, archival photographs and vintage silent-film posters.

“It’s kind of bringing forward the spirit but in a new era with kind of new bones,” Kelley said.

A building that has already lived three lives

The structure opened in 1912 as the Schiller Theater, a 400-seat silent-movie house renamed the Columbia Theater in 1918. Films stopped in 1952, and the building served several other purposes before the 4S Club — founded in 1914 by four Catholic fraternal organizations — moved in during 1962. For decades it hosted fish fries, euchre tournaments, weddings and St. Patrick’s Day parties until the pandemic and shrinking membership forced the doors shut.

Preservation meets hospitality

General manager Ryan Reidel, a veteran of the Hyde Park Restaurant Group who cut his teeth at Lindey’s under Sue Doody, said the goal is refined dining without an overly formal atmosphere.

Executive chef Erik Till, formerly of Black Creek Bistro, will run a menu of elevated comfort food. Mixologist Seth Laufman organized the cocktail list into theatrical “Acts” and an “Encore,” and the lighting can be dimmed to a candlelit glow as the night deepens.

“If you were a frequent member of the old club, your initial reaction is going to be, ‘Wow, this is completely different,’” Whitman said. “But he believes the connection becomes clearer when visitors learn the stories behind the design choices.”

Among those stories: four contemporary saint portraits by Columbus artist Grace Morbitzer Collins. St. Paul wears a motorcycle jacket referencing his road-to-Damascus conversion; St. Joseph holds the infant Jesus with woodworking tools tucked into his clothes. Collins discovered her own family name in the membership archives displayed on the walls while researching the commission.

“It’s just very, very much an honor to be involved in that,” Collins said. “I really hope that it will provide a sense of being in community with the past, with our ancestors that have been there,” she said.

Membership model aims for “inclusivity, not exclusivity”

The club will serve the public through Jan. 31, 2027, then switch to members-only access Feb. 1. Entry-level memberships start at $35 a month. The owners have identified roughly 450 people connected to the four founding societies and plan to offer them complimentary first-year memberships.

“We want to be very keen on wanting to keep this as a private members club, but we also want to carry forward this idea of inclusivity, not exclusivity,” Whitman said. “We want to make sure that any member is feeling like they’re getting more out of this club than they’re paying.”

Hours are Tuesdays through Saturdays, 4 p.m. to midnight. Membership details are at foursaintsclub.com.