Chris Columbus told Variety on Friday that a new “Home Alone” film cannot happen without Catherine O’Hara, hours before reports broke that Disney is developing a sequel with Macaulay Culkin.
The director of the 1990 original and its 1992 sequel said he had no knowledge the project was in the works. “Catherine, as I’ve always said, is 50% of ‘Home Alone,'” Columbus told Variety.
“There’s the yin and yang of ‘Home Alone’: Catherine O’Hara and Macaulay Culkin. Without those two in the film, there is no film, because they create the emotional epicenter of that film.” O’Hara, who played Kevin McCallister’s mother Kate, died January 30 at 71.
Puck reported Friday that Culkin, 46, will return for a new installment produced by Seth Rogen and Evan Goldberg through their Point Grey banner. The script grew from a pitch Culkin made to Disney film chief David Greenbaum, centering on an older Kevin as a father, according to Deadline. Rogen and Goldberg are shaping the screenplay. The Independent reported Columbus declined to comment further after the announcement.

“It was really about Catherine and Macaulay, if anyone ever wanted to do a sequel, and unfortunately that can’t happen now,” Columbus said. He also defended the original burglars, Harry and Marv, played by Joe Pesci and Daniel Stern. “Let’s not downsize Harry and Marv,” he said.
“Daniel Stern and Joe Pesci are the ultimate comic duo for that particular film. Everyone has tried in subsequent sequels to be as funny or as interesting as Dan and Joe, and they just had a chemistry that is undefinable. So you can’t do that.”
The franchise continued without Columbus and Culkin in “Home Alone 3” (1997), “Home Alone 4” (2002), “Home Alone: The Holiday Heist” (2012), and Disney+’s “Home Sweet Home Alone” (2021). Columbus has long opposed revisiting the property.
In 2020, he told Insider Disney’s planned reboot was “a waste of time” and that “nobody got in touch with me about it.” That project became “Home Sweet Home Alone.” Last year, he told Entertainment Tonight another film would be a “mistake.”
Columbus compared the ensemble to “The Goonies.” “I think you potentially could still entertain the idea of doing another ‘Home Alone’ with the cast,” he said. “Not any of these ridiculous follow-ups to the first. And I only say ridiculous because it’s weird with filmmakers. They don’t understand why that cast works so well. It’s always about the cast.”

He praised Culkin’s recent McDonald’s holiday commercial, released November 17, which recreates the Kevin McCallister character. “I love Macaulay’s McDonald’s commercial,” Columbus said. “Macaulay is a great actor, and I hope to work with him on something. Maybe it’ll be ‘Home Alone’-related, maybe it won’t.”
Rogen has a personal connection to O’Hara. She played studio executive Patty Leigh in his Apple TV+ comedy “The Studio,” a role she still held when she died. O’Hara also spoke at Culkin’s Hollywood Walk of Fame ceremony in December 2023.
Culkin told The Gentleman’s Journal in May that O’Hara’s death “hit me pretty good ’cause, you know, it was just too soon. And I felt that we had unfinished business. I definitely feel like I had unfinished business with her, you know? I feel like I owed her a favor — and I don’t like having an outstanding debt.”