ICE Makes 28 Courthouse Arrests Since Massachusetts PROTECT Act Ban Took Effect

Federal immigration agents have arrested at least 28 people at Massachusetts courthouses since Nov. 3, when a new state law took effect banning most warrantless civil immigration arrests there, the state Trial Court told GBH News, The Boston Report reported.

  • PROTECT Act courthouse provisions took effect Nov. 3, 2026
  • Trial Court documented 28 arrests through Nov. 18; advocates count 26+ without judicial warrants
  • ICE says federal law supersedes state law under the Supremacy Clause
  • Attorney General’s office has received complaints and is evaluating options

Arrests on the law’s first day

Five courthouse arrests occurred Nov. 3 — twice the daily average for such arrests in 2025, Trial Court records show, WBUR News reported. Among them was Rhyan Oliveira, 24, arrested in the lobby of Framingham District Court after a judge ordered him released on conditions in a domestic-violence case.

A plainclothes ICE agent had sat in the gallery during the hearing; two more agents appeared in the lobby with badges and handcuffed Oliveira as his mother and sister watched. His sister vomited and hyperventilated, WBUR News reported.

A search of federal court records turned up no criminal charges against Oliveira. ICE did not immediately respond to questions about his arrest, WBUR News reported.

PROTECT Act defines courthouse civil arrests as false imprisonment

The PROTECT Act, signed by Gov. Maura Healey on Aug. 5, characterizes warrantless civil arrests at courthouses as “false imprisonment” under state law and authorizes the attorney general to bring civil suits against federal officials for violations.

The law bars civil arrests at a courthouse or on its grounds unless an officer first shows a designated judge a judicial warrant or court order authorizing the arrest; civil arrests inside a courtroom are barred outright, The Boston Report reported. Arrests for federal criminal charges are not covered.

State Rep. Andy Vargas, a bill sponsor, said the protected area covers steps, plazas and walkways around the building. The attorney general can go to Superior Court to enforce the courthouse rules, Boston.com reported, according to The Boston Report.

Photo: cbsnews.com

Advocates document violations

The LUCE Immigrant Justice Network of Massachusetts says at least 26 immigrants have been arrested by the Department of Homeland Security on courthouse property since the law took effect, with no judicial warrant presented in those cases, GBH News reported. LUCE observers documented arrests in Chelsea, Medford, Peabody, Framingham, Marlborough and Malden district courts.

“Gov. Maura Healey, Attorney General Andrea Campbell and all our elected officials — our communities fought for these protections. You fought for these protections. Now, we urge you to enforce them,” said Pietra Adami, workers’ rights coordinator for the Brazilian Women’s Group and LUCE, at a State House rally Nov. 18.

Leela Ramachandran, co-director of the Metrowest Worker Center, said advocates know of at least 26 incidents without a judicial warrant, GBH News reported. Lucy Pineda, director of Latinos Unidos en Massachusetts, said she personally saw six ICE arrests at Medford District Court, including one Wednesday of a man in court for an OUI case.

The Massachusetts State House in Boston, where advocates rallied over ICE courthouse arrests under the PROTECT Act
Photo: thebostonreport.com

On Nov. 9, Lawyers for Civil Rights urged Campbell to “pursue judicial action to compel ICE’s compliance with the law,” citing arrests that day at Cambridge/Malden District Court in Medford and at Peabody District Court, The Boston Report reported.

Chilling effect on court access

Defense attorneys and advocates say ICE’s presence is deterring people from attending court. Ramachandran described a man living out of state who drove to Framingham for a warrant hearing, learned ICE was in the courthouse, and left without appearing — twice, MetroWest Daily News reported.

“Now, all of these folks are having concerns if they go to court, they’ll be taken,” Ramachandran said. “They’re choosing to stay home.” That includes people seeking restraining orders and witnesses, not just criminal defendants, MetroWest Daily News reported.

In Marlborough District Court, defense attorney Trevor Clement identified two plainclothes agents in the lobby by walking around asking each person loudly why they were there. “Be who you are. Say who you are. Know who you are. And absolutely, I’m gonna let other people know … you don’t get to skulk around,” Clement told WBUR News.

When bail was set at $5,000 for Clement’s client, he laid out the choice: “You can pay $5,000 to probably be picked up by ICE,” he said, “Or you can sit in jail until this case is over … at which point, they’ll then be standing at the doorway. Maybe.”

The client remained in state custody, but agents arrested a Brazilian woman facing a misdemeanor shoplifting charge that morning, WBUR News reported.

ICE defends courthouse arrests citing constitutional authority

ICE officials said it is “common sense” to detain suspects at courthouses, where they can find people facing criminal charges and where court security has screened them for weapons. “Sanctuary politicians do not control federal law enforcement,” an ICE spokesperson said in a statement, citing the U.S. Constitution’s supremacy clause, WBUR News reported.

Andrew Arthur, a former immigration judge and resident fellow at the Center for Immigration Studies, agreed the PROTECT Act rests on shaky legal ground. “States can’t regulate the activity of the federal government, and courthouses are public places where anybody can go,” Arthur said, WBUR News reported.

Jen Klein, director of the immigration impact unit at the Committee for Public Counsel Services, said the practice “dismantles due process” and that staff attorneys have witnessed ICE agents violating the new law. The agency is reporting incidents to the attorney general’s office, WBUR News reported.

Enforcement questions remain

The attorney general’s office said it has received complaints about ICE conduct and encourages witnesses to come forward, WBUR News reported. A spokesperson for Healey’s office said the administration is “closely monitoring reports of ICE activity in Massachusetts communities, including at courthouses” and is “in touch with the Attorney General’s Office and evaluating our options,” CBS News reported.

Social worker Jillian Phillips, a LUCE court watcher in Worcester, said the state’s tally of 28 arrests is likely an undercount. But she noted the law prohibits court staff from assisting or interfering with immigration arrests. “Even if court officers do see it happening, you can’t interfere with a federal arrest. So then, what actual options exist to hold people accountable?” Phillips told WBUR News.

Before the PROTECT Act, courts allowed agents into sallyports and lockups to take defendants into custody behind closed doors. Now, Phillips said, “We at least now have the opportunity to physically see the person and try to get help for them, whereas before, sometimes you didn’t know if they took someone or not,” WBUR News reported.

The attorney general’s office did not return a request for comment, CBS News reported.