A Fruitland woman charged with first-degree murder in the disappearance of 5-year-old Michael Vaughan repeatedly asked officers if they had “found him yet” while they searched her home last week, according to court filings obtained by Court TV.
Sarah Wondra, 39, was arrested Nov. 10 and booked into the Payette County Jail on a $1 million bond. She appeared virtually for her arraignment Thursday and pleaded not guilty to charges of first-degree murder, second-degree kidnapping and destruction of evidence. Her husband, Stacey Wondra, was charged Oct. 30 with the same counts.
Stacey Wondra has been charged with the kidnapping and murder of 5-year-old Michael Vaughan, who vanished in Fruitland, Idaho, in July 2021. Law&Crime's Angenette Levy @angenette5 goes through the heartbreaking case. pic.twitter.com/6siOQlc3VI
Michael vanished while playing outside his Fruitland neighborhood on July 27, 2021. A probable cause affidavit by Fruitland Police Detective Juanita Kelleher details a timeline showing Sarah Wondra drove her maroon GMC pickup out of the neighborhood at 7:08 p.m. that evening — after the boy was reported missing — and returned more than four hours later towing a silver Mercedes-Benz, according to the Idaho Statesman.
Stacey Wondra told investigators he witnessed his wife carrying Michael in a duffel bag and saw her and two former roommates duct-tape the child. He claimed the boy died accidentally, suffocating inside the bag, and said the couple later buried the body in their yard, Court TV reported. Multiple K-9 units alerted to areas of the property, but no remains have been found.

Prosecutors said the GMC truck seen in surveillance video was later repossessed and appeared to have been “thoroughly cleaned” before the repossession company took possession, according to Court TV.
The affidavit describes a distinct change in Sarah Wondra’s behavior after the disappearance. She began standing along the highway near a Love’s Gas Station in Ontario, Oregon, holding signs urging people to repent because the end of time was near.
Her social media activity surged: from three Facebook posts in the first seven months of 2021 to 343 between August and December, and from 11 TikTok videos in the prior three years to 329 between mid-September and late December 2021, the Idaho Statesman reported. The posts were “very religious and spoke about repentance and forgiveness,” the affidavit said.
#BREAKING: Fruitland police chief has confirmed they are looking for remains, following up on a very credible tip https://t.co/YhA7wXfyuK
In TikTok videos, Wondra made “testimony” statements regarding her involvement in criminal behaviors and stated she had broken all ten of the Ten Commandments, prosecutors noted in the affidavit obtained by Court TV.
“It should be noted that ‘thou shalt not kill’ is one of the Ten Commandments,” the filing said. Wondra also alleged in videos that her sins did not matter because God had forgiven her. Michael’s missing person flyer is visible in the background of some videos.
During the search of her home last week, officers documented several comments by Sarah Wondra, including: “Wow, that is a lot; I definitely did not kill that boy,” and “Oh, wow, wow, the most high God just told me that Stacey was the one who killed him, and he buried him in the yard of Carson’s house,” according to Court TV.
She also told officers, “He wants me to make sure you understand that I had nothing to do with it.”
Prosecutors dropped a previous charge against Sarah Wondra — failure to report Michael’s death — in April 2023 after filing it in November 2022, the Idaho Statesman reported. Michael has not been found.