Idaho Fish and Game Commissioner to Plead Guilty in Poaching Case

Brody Harshbarger will avoid jail time after agreeing to plead guilty to misdemeanor hunting charges stemming from a December poaching case.

The plea agreement filed in court requires Harshbarger to pay a $500 fine per charge, accept a one-year revocation of his hunting privileges, and serve six months of probation. He is scheduled for sentencing before a Fremont County judge on Dec. 9.

Idaho Fish and Game Commissioner Charged with Poaching Bull Elk: Full Story — Traffic Accident Files

The case began after an Idaho Department of Fish and Game law enforcement officer responded to a Citizens Against Poaching hotline call on Dec. 20, 2025, according to court records.

According to charging documents, both Harshbarger and Eric Murphy discharged firearms across Spring Hollow Road, with Harshbarger firing from the driver’s seat of his automobile. Court filings reveal that an antlerless bull elk was illegally taken on Bureau of Reclamation property, while a six-point bull elk was improperly harvested on private land.

Under the agreement, prosecutors will drop five other misdemeanor charges. The dropped accusations comprise a charge for hunting with a motorized vehicle’s assistance, two counts of illegally taking or killing a big game animal, an offense for trespassing with the intent to hunt or fish, and a count of failing to make a reasonable attempt at recovering a six-point bull elk.

Idaho Department of Fish and Game Commissioner Charged For Alleged Elk Poaching — KREM 2 News

Gov. Brad Little appointed Harshbarger to the commission in 2024 to represent the Upper Snake Region, replacing Derick Attebury. Harshbarger’s appointment was scheduled to run through June 30.

After the charges became public in March, Harshbarger agreed to postpone the performance of his duties as an Idaho Fish and Game commissioner. Zach Hague, Little’s then-chief of staff, confirmed in a March 10 letter that Harshbarger would postpone performing commissioner responsibilities until the criminal matter concluded.

Idaho Fish and Game Commissioner to Plead Guilty in Poaching Case
Photo: kpvi.com

Emily Callihan, the governor’s communications director, said on Monday that Harshbarger had not officially resigned from his post. However, his profile was removed from the Idaho Fish and Game website.

“Governor Little will be working with the Idaho Department of Fish and Game and stakeholders in the coming days to ensure the responsibilities of the position are fulfilled,” Callihan wrote in an email.

Idaho fish and game commissioner is being charged for long list of hunting violations — MeatEater Podcast Network