Idaho Incarcerates Women at Highest US Rate as Crime Falls

Idaho locked up women at a higher rate than any other state in 2023, even as reported crime dropped for two decades.

A new report from the legislature’s Office of Performance Evaluation found the state’s overall incarceration rate ranked seventh nationally, Boise State Public Radio reported. The review, authored by Christopher Shank, traced the surge to drug possession cases filling beds freed up by successful reductions in DUI and domestic violence offenses.

“Drug possession filled beds freed up by those successes, largely through returns from probation, parole and retained jurisdiction and with an outsized effect on women,” Shank wrote.

Lawmakers passed more than 150 criminal justice bills between 2005 and 2025, largely stiffening penalties or creating new crimes. Most other states moved the opposite direction, reducing penalties or expanding rehabilitation programs, Shank told the Joint Legislative Oversight Committee on Wednesday.

The data Shank obtained from state agencies did not specify which drugs led to prison sentences or the role of mental health. But Idaho Supreme Court statistics showed methamphetamine was the drug of choice for roughly 5,000 drug court participants — 48 percent — followed by heroin and other opiates at 20 percent, alcohol at 16 percent and marijuana at 13 percent.

Business concepts hr department increasing employee engagement worker performance evaluation human resourses personal staff

Parole revocations spiked around 2016. The report suggested a rise in “technical violations” — such as refusing a search or associating with known gang members rather than committing a new crime — may reflect a departmental shift toward deterring new offenses by revoking supervision earlier.

While property crime plummeted, Idaho’s felony theft threshold remained frozen at $1,000 since 1998. “We haven’t adjusted that threshold for inflation despite the value of the dollar essentially being cut in half over that time,” Shank said. A $1,000 item today equated to roughly $500 in 1998 dollars.

“If we have an opportunity here to, as policymakers, step in and help figure out what the solution is and create policy and fund that that helps solve these problems, we’re solving so many downstream problems that are being created,” said Sen. Dave Lent, R-Idaho Falls.

The committee directed OPE to determine when it could issue recommendations before the 2027 legislative session begins in January.