Coach Nicholas Ellis faces a misdemeanor battery charge after a student said he slapped her leg on October 13, WKRC reported.
The student was on an exercise bike in the athletic training and rehabilitation room at New Albany High School. Court documents show Ellis leaned against the bike and changed its speed, which made the student feel uncomfortable. He left, then returned shortly after.
Before leaving the second time, Ellis slapped the back of the student’s thigh, according to court documents cited by WDRB+WAVE. The student told police that contact made her feel extremely uncomfortable.

She reported the incident to her coach. That coach observed redness on the student’s legs and markings consistent with fingerprints.
When police spoke with Ellis by phone, he admitted to hitting the student. However, he offered a different characterization of the physical contact.
Police said Ellis claimed he did it as a “pat” and in a “kind gesture way,” according to WDRB+WAVE reporting.
The school website lists Ellis as the head coach of the boys’ cross-country team, as well as a teacher at the school. New Albany-Floyd County Schools declined to comment on the incident. The district confirmed that Ellis no longer works for the district.
Gretchen Ragains, the lawyer representing Ellis, provided a statement regarding her client’s character and standing in the community.

“Mr. Ellis has spent years mentoring and supporting his athletes, earning the respect of current and former runners alike,” said Gretchen Ragains, Ellis’ lawyer, told WDRB+WAVE. “Counsel has been in contact with members of the cross-country team, including individuals who witnessed the alleged incident, as well as former students and runners who have voluntarily and independently come forward to express their overwhelming support for Mr. Ellis and his character. We ask that the community reserve judgment and allow the facts to come to light before drawing conclusions.”
According to Hoodline, the initial hearing in the case had not been held by November 18, 2026.
New Albany High School, founded in 1853 as Scribner High School, is the oldest public high school in Indiana. The school closed from 1859 to 1864 when the building served as a Union hospital during the Civil War.
It later operated the nation’s first FCC-licensed high school FM radio station, WNAS 88.1 FM, and counts astronomer Edwin Hubble among its former faculty, where he taught physics and Spanish and coached basketball in the early 20th century.
The Indiana Department of Education maintains public databases regarding educator misconduct and educator conviction information, noting that only verified convictions are posted publicly.