The Irmo Fire District filed a settlement offer on November 16 that demands the firing of Columbia Fire Chief Aubrey Jenkins and Assistant Chief Anthony Holloway.
The proposal, submitted in Richland County Common Pleas Court, also seeks roughly $40,296 in legal fees, written apologies from both men published in The State and The Post and Courier within 30 days, and dismissal of all claims against the district with prejudice, according to court filings. The offer gives the city 20 days to accept and states it is not an admission of liability.
The case stems from the May 26, 2023 collapse at the Tropical Ridge apartment complex that killed 25-year-old James Michael Muller and trapped three other Irmo firefighters. Emma Elizabeth Muller, his wife and estate representative, sued the city of Columbia and Richland County; the city then brought Irmo Fire in as a third-party defendant.
The allegations behind the apologies
The district’s filing targets two specific accusations it calls false. It wants Jenkins to apologize for allegedly stating that Irmo Fire or its employees gave false statements to agencies investigating the fire. It wants Holloway to apologize for allegedly saying that Sloane Valentino authored the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health report on the incident.

“The district describes those allegations as false,” the court document says. The apologies would be submitted to the state’s two largest newspapers for publication within a month of acceptance.
What the NIOSH report found
A NIOSH report released in April 2025 cited communication failures, problems tracking firefighters on the fireground, and an inadequate understanding of the building’s structural risks. According to the report, crews were not adequately informed that a second-floor area was sagging, and it described confusion among supervisors after the collapse.

Irmo Fire Chief Michael Sonefeld said the department concurred with the findings and had taken steps to address the cited shortcomings, according to The State’s reporting.
Parallel litigation and what comes next
In a separate lawsuit, Jenkins sued the Professional Fire Fighters Association of South Carolina and its president, Roger Odachowski, alleging they falsely blamed him for conditions that contributed to a firefighter’s death in the 2023 fire. Jenkins denied the association’s allegations.
Founded in 1963, Irmo Fire District operates as a special purpose district covering about 33 square miles across two counties and one municipality, serving a population of roughly 46,000 to 50,000. Its 43 career personnel run from three stations and answer approximately 4,800 calls annually, providing fire suppression, auto extrication, swift water rescue, rope rescue and first responder care.
If the city rejects the offer or the 20-day window expires, the case proceeds toward trial.
Worth a look
- Jeff Bzdawka Says Lifetime Award Represents Team Effort, Not Solo Work
- Atrium Health Rolls Out Visitor Restrictions, Mask Rule Starting Thursday
- Mass. Maritime Assistant Football Coach Charged With Child Sexual Exploitation, Posing as Teen to Target Minors (world-today-news.com)
- England rugby team needs fire and pride to beat New Zealand, says Borthwick (newsarchyuk.com)