JEA Calculates Vickie Cavey’s Annual Pension at $451,689, Pending Board Approval

The City of Jacksonville Pension Office calculated former JEA CEO Vickie Cavey’s annual pension at $451,689, pending board approval on December 17.

Former JEA CEO Vickie Cavey’s annual pension benefit has been calculated at $451,688.66 by the City of Jacksonville Pension Office.

This figure, which the Pension Board of Trustees will ratify on December 17, shows a higher retirement compensation than before.

The Bottom Line:

  • The calculated annual payout of $451,689 is nearly four times the $119,614.84 pension Cavey was entitled to when she first retired in 2016.
  • The total exceeds the 2027 IRS limit for pension payments, set at $300,000, leaving JEA to determine if it will utilize an excess-benefit arrangement to cover the difference.
  • The calculation uses a 2.5% accrual rate and includes salary data from April 2016 through October 2026, combining prior service with her CEO tenure.

The mechanism behind this payout rests on the City of Jacksonville’s General Employees Pension Plan, which calculates benefits based on the highest-paid 36 consecutive months of compensation within an employee’s final decade of service.

Cavey’s return to the utility and subsequent appointment as CEO in 2024 allowed for a sharp rise in her pensionable earnings. In February 2025, the JEA board authorized a contract extension that pushed her annual salary to $700,000.

This structure permits retirees who return to the plan for at least one year to blend their historical service records with more recent, higher-compensated periods. Because Cavey’s tenure included 32 years of credited service, she reached the plan’s 80% accrual cap. The resulting calculation exceeds the $120,000 annual figure she received after retiring in 2016.

Retired JEA CEO in line for $451K annual pension payout — The Florida Times-Union

The $451,689 figure remains provisional until the board meeting on December 17. Because the amount surpasses the $300,000 IRS ceiling for 2027, the utility faces a policy choice regarding the surplus. JEA has not disclosed whether it will facilitate an excess-benefit arrangement, which is a voluntary mechanism, to ensure the full calculated amount is paid to the former executive.

“It’s nearly quadruple what she was receiving before she served as CEO, and that astronomical jump is all due to the way the city’s pension payouts are calculated.”

While the pension office maintains that the calculation adheres to existing plan formulas, the optics of a nearly half-million-dollar annual payout follow a period of intense scrutiny.

Cavey resigned from her position on September 25, 2026, amid a City Council inquiry into workplace complaints and contested capacity fees. Though an external legal review found no proof of a toxic environment or discriminatory practices, the board's decision to defend her record highlights the tension between institutional governance and public oversight.

The final determination on December 17 will signal whether the utility intends to move forward with the excess-benefit arrangement or adhere strictly to IRS caps.

Jacksonville, situated on the Atlantic coast of northeastern Florida, is the largest city by total area in the contiguous United States, encompassing 900 square miles. Originally settled at a river crossing known as “Cow Ford,” the city was formally platted in 1822 and named for Andrew Jackson, the first military governor of the Florida Territory.

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and market analysis purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, or legal advice. Always consult with a certified financial professional before making investment decisions.