Pima County Superior Court Judge Jeffrey Bergin granted a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction Tuesday that clears Arizona forward RJ Godfrey to play for the 12th-ranked Wildcats against No. 3 UConn on Wednesday, Arizona Sports reported.
The ruling ends a months-long legal odyssey that bounced the 6-foot-8, 240-pound fifth-year forward between courts in Georgia, Texas and Colorado before landing in Tucson. Bergin based his order on NCAA Bylaw 12.6, which he determined is a binding contract between the association and its member schools and contains no written exclusion for athletes who graduated high school in 2022.
“RJ is such a good individual, and he’s deserving of this opportunity,” UA coach Tommy Lloyd said after the hearing. “And this is a kind of a great step forward.”
News: Judge clears RJ Godfrey to play for Arizona in fifth season of college basketball. Could be a huge decision that changes Arizona's outlook this season. Story via @cameronsalerno1: https://t.co/aQBw6zZqc3
Godfrey sued the Arizona Board of Regents on Nov. 5 for breach of contract after the university declined to certify his eligibility, a strategy that differed from the suits filed directly against the NCAA by other “five-for-five” plaintiffs. His attorneys, Ryan Downton and Ali Farhang, noted in court that of the 22 such players across 13 Big 12 teams, Godfrey had been the only one ruled ineligible.
The legal zigzag
Godfrey’s path to this point reads like a case study in forum shopping. He first joined a group lawsuit in Georgia seeking a fifth year under the NCAA’s new “five-for-five” eligibility model, which grants five years of total competition within a five-year window. The Georgia Court of Appeals granted the NCAA a stay, leaving his future in limbo.
Godfrey and his attorneys sued the Arizona Board of Regents on Nov. 5, seeking a permanent injunction for eligibility. Godfrey and the other players withdrew from their Georgia “five-for-five” case and refiled in Texas after oral arguments in the Georgia suit were not scheduled until Jan. 12, well into the college basketball season.

Rather than wait on that timeline, Godfrey’s camp sued the Board of Regents in Pima County, arguing the university was contractually bound to follow the NCAA manual it had agreed to uphold.
ABOR’s two attorneys did not cross-examine witnesses at Tuesday’s hearing, offering only a brief statement supporting Godfrey’s case. Athletic director Desiree Reed-Francois, who was subpoenaed, did not appear but submitted an affidavit in support that was read into the record.
Roster ripple effects
The absence of Godfrey forced Lloyd to shift freshman standout Ivan Kharchenkov — arguably the team’s best perimeter defender — from small forward to power forward. Starters Derek Dixon and Kharchenkov testified Tuesday that the shortage had inflated their minutes and disrupted developmental timelines for younger players. Lloyd told the court Godfrey was recruited to be the starting four and would not block younger players who still need seasoning.
RJ Godfrey has won his legal battle to become eligible and suit up for Arizona men's basketball. Though not a certainty, that could be Wednesday night vs. #3 UConn. https://t.co/yfPGN8FR5W
“(Godfrey) puts the pieces in the right place for our roster to kind of have the depth it needs to have and kind of the impact we would love to have off the bench,”
Godfrey averaged 12.0 points, 5.3 rebounds and 1.6 assists last season at Clemson, where he led the Tigers in scoring and helped knock off Arizona in the 2024 Sweet 16. He began his career at Clemson (two seasons), transferred to Georgia for 2024-25 (33 starts, 6.4 points, 3.8 rebounds), then returned to Clemson before entering the portal again.
NCAA may appeal or suspend Godfrey for agent ties
The NCAA was not a named party in Tuesday’s suit, leaving open the possibility it could appeal or impose a separate suspension tied to Godfrey’s participation in the Reese’s College All-Star Game and his prior signing with an agent.
Godfrey testified he was not paid for the all-star game, received only training advances from the agent, and has since repaid that money. If a suspension is levied, Arizona hopes the exhibitions in Lithuania, three home preseason games and the first four regular-season contests will count as time served.

Nearly the entire Wildcats roster and coaching staff attended the hearing, with several players sitting in the jury box. “It just reminds me of what great guys we have and what a great culture that we have in our program,” Lloyd said.
Godfrey must still be certified by the NCAA before taking the floor Wednesday at ALKEME Arena. Tipoff against the Huskies is scheduled for 9 p.m. ET.
NEWS: RJ Godfrey has been GRANTED a preliminary injunction by a judge in Pima County and is now eligible to play for Arizona, per @BrucePascoe pic.twitter.com/7HZrtZgAYp