Jury Awards $6 Million to Former Wyoming Boys’ School Resident Over Punitive Isolation

A federal jury in Casper awarded a former resident of the Wyoming Boys’ School $6 million late Thursday, finding that staff subjected him to punitive isolation and denied him due process at the state-run juvenile facility near Worland, WyoFile reported.

The unanimous verdict followed an eight-day trial in U.S. District Court that pulled back the curtain on conditions inside the 38-acre campus overseen by the Department of Family Services.

Jurors deliberated about seven hours before holding Superintendent Dale Weber and Dorm Supervisor Mike Nelson liable for violating Blaise Chivers-King’s Fourteenth Amendment rights during multiple stints in 7-by-10-foot cinderblock detention rooms in 2020 and 2021. The jury rejected Chivers-King’s excessive-force claim against Security Manager Thad Shaffer.

“We are so proud of our client,” attorney Allison Mahoney told WyoFile. “This was not easy for him to sit in court and listen to testimony.” Co-counsel Ciara Boerman said the verdict “sent a strong message in recognizing that this is wrong.”

Jury Awards $6 Million to Former Wyoming Boys' School Resident Over Punitive Isolation
Photo: wyomingnews.com

The conditions on trial

Attorneys showed the jury images of the windowless detention rooms — white cinderblock, a toilet, a mattress provided only at night, and a magnet sometimes covering the door window. Chivers-King testified that confinement felt arbitrary; staff kept him locked down even after he had calmed down, and on occasion for predetermined stretches regardless of behavior. One stint lasted 15 days.

“Even when he did what he was supposed to do, they kept him in there.”

Boerman told jurors in closing arguments.

Video and logbook entries presented at trial showed Chivers-King banging his head against the wall and attempting to strangle himself while isolated. “The vast majority of that time he spent with his own thoughts, thinking about how to end his life,” Boerman said during closing arguments.

A “culture of total control”

Testimony showed what daily life was like at the school. Psychiatrist Stuart Grassian, an expert witness for the plaintiff, described “a culture of total control and domination, and really, not in any way responsive to the psychiatric situation of these kids,” WyoFile reported. His evaluation drew partly on a 2023 visit by the Council of Juvenile Justice Administrators.

Chivers-King described an intake process where staff shaved his head and ordered him to keep his eyes down. “I felt like a hopeless sheep,” he testified, per WyoFile. Daily routines included intercom announcements — “You’re still in the Wyoming Boys’ School, this ain’t the dream no more” — and silent meals where residents pushed back chairs, placed hands on knees, said “done, sir,” and looked down.

Weber acknowledged that staff required boys to walk in single-file lines, eyes forward, monitored by officers on four-wheelers, and barred verbal and nonverbal communication between residents. “We try to make sure that the boys aren’t communicating nonverbally because most of the time, it doesn’t lead to good things in a facility like ours,” Weber testified, according to WyoFile.

The defense and the Gilmore factor

Defense attorney Scott Ortiz argued that staff were responding to safety concerns under extraordinary circumstances, noting Chivers-King’s time at the school coincided with the COVID-19 pandemic. “I cannot think about a more difficult task than having to fulfill their legitimate governmental objectives under those circumstances,” Ortiz told jurors.

Defense attorneys highlighted Chivers-King’s behavioral history and moments of sudden violence — punching, kicking, head-butting, and biting staff — after appearing calm. They also attempted to shift responsibility to former Superintendent Gary Gilmore, who retired in March 2022 and has since died.

Weber, who served as deputy and interim superintendent under Gilmore, testified that Gilmore’s management style was “very authoritarian” and that “I don’t believe I had any authority to challenge his decisions,” WyoFile reported.

But Boerman noted in closing that Weber and Nelson signed documents related to Chivers-King’s detention. “That’s convenient, but that’s not accountability,” she said.

Mike Nelson, testifying in his own defense, said he believed he had a good relationship with Chivers-King, who called him at home twice on Halloween and twice after leaving the facility. Nelson described making Chivers-King clean his own blood after head-banging incidents: “There’s an obvious biohazard present. It’s the safest way to clean a biohazard,” he testified, per WyoFile.

Former employee Robin McIntosh, who worked at the school from 2007 until March 2026, offered a contrasting account. He testified that staff confined Chivers-King “very frequently” and for too long. “He would actively degrade the longer he was in there. It was a good excuse to keep him in there because he wasn’t meeting expectations,” McIntosh said. Defense attorneys suggested McIntosh was motivated by workplace conflicts.

Five more lawsuits await trial

Chivers-King’s case was the first of six lawsuits filed by former residents to reach trial. The next is scheduled to begin Dec. 7. Mahoney said she hopes the verdict spurs legislative action: “I hope this sends a message that legislation needs to be enacted in Wyoming to address solitary confinement,” she told WyoFile.